Full menu with prices & pictures
Freshy Fresh Bagels 917 Montauk Hwy, Shirley I-11967-211...
(+1)6312812243
Order food online for delivery
The eatery is also easily accessible by public transportation. The closest station is LIRR-Mastic Shirley, which is 443 meters away, otherwise, there are places to park 489 meters away at Mastic-Shirley Station.
A comprehensive menu of Freshy Fresh Bagels from Shirley covering all 13 menus and drinks can be found here on the menu.
At Freshy Fresh Bagels in Shirley, we are passionate about serving hearty and delicious American food. Our menu is designed to hit the spot with dishes like our flavorful chicken. We take pride in ensuring that each dish is perfectly made without skimping on anything. Come visit us today and see what we have to offer! Call (631) 281-2243 for more information.
What User likes about Freshy Fresh Bagels:
Came from FL to visit family (5 years ago from Shirley) and needed Bagels to take home. Wasn't busy when I showed up at 11:15. My sister's husband recommended we go because he works for her tree service. Not disappointed. I can't wait for everyone to try what NY Bagels are! We cannot get decent bagels in FL because of the water quality. I was greeted and immediately maintained. The prices were decent and the cream ch... View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Freshy Fresh Bagels:
Went to bagel shop next thing you know one of the workers scanned my card and have taken all my money from bank account. Still under investigation. Please don’t go to this bagel shop. Workers there will scan your card so be careful View all feedback.
I enjoyed some good coffee and decent bagels at this clean establishment, although the service...
This is the best bagel shop on the island! The bagels are consistently fresh! Every summer when...
I visited Freshy Fresh a few weeks ago, and the woman who took my order provided me with some i...
June 2022 , WOW WHAT RIPOFF ALL PRICING ... and you the client buyers are the issue . Bagel STO...
Very disappointed. Bagels were not fresh at all. Ordered them through an app. They were definit...