Full menu with prices & pictures
Carlo's Pizza Of Shi... 451 Glen Dr, 11967, Shirley, United...
+16319248760
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Carlo's Pizza Of Shi...
The Card of Carlo's Pizza Of Shirley from Shirley includes about 245 different dishes and drinks. On average, you pay for a dish / drink about $13.1.
Carlo's Pizza Shirley in Shirley, NY offers delicious Italian cuisine with vegetarian options. Operating hours are from 10:30 AM to 11:00 PM. Contact (631) 924-8760 to make a reservation or order through DoorDash. Check out Your Bagel Cafe and Okeno Sushi for similar dining experiences. Leave a review if you've dined here before!.
Carlo's Pizzeria has garnered a mix of opinions, revealing a divide among patrons. On one hand, many customers celebrate the restaurant’s family-owned charm, fresh ingredients, and diverse specialty pizza offerings. They praise the quick service and reasonable prices, often recommending dishes like BBQ and Hawaiian pizzas. Conversely, some diners express disappointment, citing issues with burnt or undercooked meals, incorrect orders, and a decline in service quality. Despite these mixed reviews, the consistent theme remains: Carlo's dedication to quality pizza keeps families returning, making it a popular choice in the local dining scene.
Carlos is excellent! The food is great, I try to get it when I jonesing for some good Italians!...
Familial restaurant with high-quality food too good value. High pick-up traffic. Drinks of well...
I absolutely love this restaurant! It is family-owned and always bustling, which is a testament...
Hands down 1 of the best pizzerias in Suffolk County. A absolute MUST stop if going east or wes...
This used to be one of my favorite pizza places. It is now run by a bunch of teenagers who care...