Tony D's - Rochester

Virgil's BBQ is a popular spot that receives mixed reviews. While some love the food, service, and atmosphere, others have had disappointing experiences. One complaint involved a $77 seafood special that caused illness, undercooked shrimp, and rubbery lobster. Another diner found the meatballs and arancini balls lackluster and the ambiance lacking warmth. However, those who enjoyed their experience raved about the food, service, and portions, especially praising dishes like the Shrimp Scampi and Zipp Di Pesce. Some also highlighted the great wine selection and attentive service. Overall, Virgil's seems to be a hit or miss depending on individual experiences, with some diners willing to return for the good food despite minor issues like loud music or cleanliness concerns in the kitchen.