Full menu with prices & pictures
Matthew's Seafood Ho... 935 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, New York,...
+16315838016
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Matthew's Seafood Ho...
What Scott Weinstein likes about Matthew's Seafood House:
I had a fantastic meal that kicked off the summer of 2016. I know I should have opted for fish, but I'm not a fish eater! I simply couldn't resist the Chicken Parmesan on the menu, and it turned out to be one of the best I've ever had. I wouldn't have considered Italian food on Fire Island, but now that I've tried it, I’ll find it hard to resist ordering it again when I return. View all feedback.
One of the best restaurants in Ocean Beach food and staff are amazing.The music on Wednesdays w...
Best food on the island.. hands down.. you must experience the food and the beautiful views
Excellent atmosphere, food and service Cody was wonderful Would always recommend Matthews
Matthews is by far the best place on Fire Island!!! They make the the best Rocket Fuel on the I...
The best food and view on fire island. Been going for about 20 years.