Full menu with prices & pictures
Mary Jane's Dairy 5334 Route 9w, Newburgh I-12550-1323...
+18455618450
Reserve a table now for Mary Jane's Dairy
A complete menu of Mary Jane's Dairy from Newburgh covering all 28 dishes and drinks can be found here on the card.
What User likes about Mary Jane's Dairy:
This morning my mother asked for two different flavors of ice cream from Mary Jane's. I messaged them and to my surprise, they answered right away. One flavor butter pecan) they make. The other request, orange and vanilla swirl) they don't. They had an incredible suggestion. Half orange sherbet and half soft vanilla. They put each half long ways down the container so she would have some of both with each scoop. It wa... View all feedback.
WARNING: Place is temporarily closed. It was boarded up and looked like there was a fire. One M...
Best around. We usually get root beer floats or sundaes. Always a great experience!
Some of the best ice cream in New York. Go now thank me later.
Awesome icecream. I do not recommend the dipped waffle cones; they rated stale. But the icecrea...
I love the variety of delicious ice cream flavors at Mary Jane's and their ice cream sandwiches...