Cody's Diner - New Haven
Cody's Diner
Menu
A comprehensive menu of Cody's Diner from New Haven featuring all 2 meals and drinks can be found here on the list.
Cody's Diner, located in the heart of New Haven, CT, is a beloved American eatery with an inviting atmosphere and an average rating of 3.5 stars. Open 24 hours, from midnight to just before midnight the next day, it’s the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings at any hour. To ensure a seamless dining experience, consider calling ahead to reserve your table at (203) 562-0044, especially during peak times. For those who prefer enjoying their meals at home, Cody's Diner offers delivery through popular services like Uber Eats and DoorDash. The menu features a variety of organic options alongside other delicious dishes, complemented by great coffee to keep you energized. If you're looking for similar dining experiences, be sure to check out Libby's Italian Pastry Shop and Zeneli Pizzeria e cucina Napoletana. Have you dined with us before? We’d love to hear your thoughts—leave a review!.
Images
Feedback
Nestled in a quiet commercial area, this diner presents a mixed bag of dining experiences. While patrons appreciate the friendly staff and clean environment, the food quality proves inconsistent. Several have encountered mix-ups with orders and lackluster dishes, particularly during busy lunch hours. Though some guests report enjoyable meals, others highlight disappointing service and unfulfilled promises from staff. In terms of ambiance, the eatery is a no-frills spot popular among locals, but its limited menu and occasional greasy offerings might not satisfy everyone. Late-night patrons will find it one of the few open options, albeit offering only takeout.
Just wanted to pick up some meatballs and sauce to bring home to serve with dinner. They put sauce in a Styrofoam container (which doesn’t seal) and handed to me in a paper bag. I got in my car, sat it down on the seat and proceeded to drive home. Sauce went all over. I called to recommend they not do that to anyone else. My car seat was a mess and I was burnt from the hot sauce. they had little to no response.
The first time I ordered from this restaurant, I requested a chicken salad wrap, but when I got home, I found out that they had given me a tuna wrap instead. They said they tried to call me, but I never received a phone call. As someone who has worked in the food service industry for years, I would have expected them to swap the chicken salad for a different wrap with chicken in case of allergies or dislikes. Despite this mishap, I decided to give the place another chance, but I regretted it. I ordered a chicken souvlaki sandwich, which was extremely greasy and had cooked diced tomatoes and peppers on it instead of the traditional cold lettuce and tomatoes. Additionally, the tzatziki sauce cup was placed inside the container and became so hot from the food that it curdled and almost spilled everywhere. I will not be ordering from this place again, as I cannot understand how their reviews are so positive.
Came highly recommended. Our first attempt came when the owner closed for the 1st time since opening. Glad we came back! Located on a quiet industrial like road with newer upgrades; striping, bikelanes, paving etc. Surface parking lot as well as area street parking. Stopped in for a specific type of breakfast meal and they nailed it! Owner on site, mix of clientele including law enforcement, students, old friends and locals.
Just wanted to pick up some meatballs and sauce to bring home to serve with dinner. They put sauce in a Styrofoam container (which doesn?t seal) and handed to me in a paper bag. I got in my car, sat it down on the seat and proceeded to drive home.Sauce went all over. I called to recommend they not do that to anyone else. My car seat was a mess and I was burnt from the hotsauce. they had little to no response.
I used to enjoy dining at this restaurant, as it was a good place to eat. However, my recent experience with a Grubhub order was disappointing. The sandwich I received was dry, with no Mayo as requested, and the bread was hard. The steak and cheese filling was cold. I called to address the issue and was told by someone named Lincoln that I could receive two free subs on my next visit. However, the staff now claims that Lincoln does not work there. Joanne, another staff member, also gave a bad attitude and made false promises. I have included photos for reference. It seems that there may be some miscommunication and dishonesty among the staff.
Full Menu
Burger
Hot Drinks
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.4 / 5 (3406 reviews)Global International American Cheese
ZINC New Haven
Chapel Street 964, 06510-2517 New Haven, US
- ★ 4.4 / 5 (3475 reviews)#21 Seafood in New Haven French
Union League Cafe
Chapel St 1032, 06510-2402 New Haven, US
- ★ 4.7 / 5 (2981 reviews)Spanish Mediterranean Coffee Fish Meat
olea - New Haven
High Street 39, 06510-2308 New Haven, US