Papa Carlo Pizzeria Gelati - Lockport

On this site, you can find the complete menu of Papa Carlo Pizzeria Gelati from Lockport. Currently, there are 36 meals and drinks available.

Nestled in Selkirk, this restaurant boasts a varied reputation, especially for its pizza. While some diners rave about the flavorful, crispy crust and delicious toppings—particularly enjoying the unique white cream sauce—others express disappointment, citing underwhelming portions and incorrectly prepared orders. The establishment's ice cream has also garnered mixed reviews, described as mediocre and unworthy of a special trip. However, patrons praise the attentive service and pleasant dining atmosphere, making it a solid choice for a casual date night. Currently, the restaurant is temporarily closed due to a fire, leaving loyal customers eager for its return.