Sheetz - Johnstown

#14 - Mexican - Johnstown, American, North American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Sheetz

Sheetz
2.5 / 5 (54 reviews)

Description

**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag at Sheetz**

A visit to Sheetz reveals a blend of convenience and culinary disappointment. Guests have reported frequent issues with orders, such as missing items and overcooked ingredients, leading to a lackluster dining experience. The drive-thru has drawn criticism for slow service, with food often arriving cold after long waits. While some appreciate the location’s convenience, particularly for families, the overall food quality fails to meet expectations. Patrons suggest exploring other nearby options for a more satisfying meal, as the inconsistent service and complaints about food preparation tarnish what could be a convenient stop for quick bites.

Last update: 09.07.2026 from: Kellen

Feedback

★ 2.5 / 5 from 54 reviews
kellen-kensinger
19.02.2025

I ordered 2 hot dogs and a milkshake from the night crew here just a few minutes ago and it was a bad experience. First they didn't have pretzel rolls, which I was fine with, but they didn't refund me for not having the rolls. Then the 2 hot dogs werediscolored inside and were cold. The milkshake would be the best part but that had a ton of ice chunks in it too. The night crewalso made it very publicly known how they hate making shakes and hate it when people order them. Scalp Ave blows this place outof the water and they will be receiving my business for now on instead.

j-smith-doctor777
19.02.2025

I specifically asked for only pickles on a 2 for $6 late-night bites burger, but my request seemed to have been completely overlooked because it arrived with all the usual toppings. Additionally, the Wisconsin cheese bites were overcooked. I won’t be dining at this Sheetz again.

brian-cernic
19.02.2025

In my last two visits for drive-thru orders, I had to wait at least 10 minutes each time. Today, my food sat in the window for around 7 minutes before anyone took my payment (it was only 28 degrees outside). By the time I got home, everything was cold. If you decide to visit, I would recommend avoiding the drive-thru.

emma-davis-rabbit0
19.02.2025

I had a disappointing experience with the cashier, Alex. He was quite rude and even yelled at me when I entered the wrong PIN for my card. It seems that customer service might not be the right fit for him given his lack of patience.

kayley-jones
17.03.2023

I had a disappointing experience at the restaurant due to the cashier, Alex, who was quite rude. When I accidentally entered the wrong PIN for my card, he yelled at me. It’s clear that he lacks the patience necessary for a customer service role.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.