Shortstop Deli - Ithaca
Shortstop Deli
Menu
The restaurant from Ithaca offers 90 different dishes and drinks on the menu at an average price of $6.4.
Shortstop Deli in Ithaca, NY is a popular American restaurant with an impressive 4.4-star rating. Open from 7:00 AM to 9:00 PM, it offers a quick visit experience. For a similar meal, you can also try Gorgers or Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop. Share your favorite dish with us and leave a review!.
Images
Feedback
A beloved local deli in Ithaca draws praise for its generous, freshly made sandwiches, vibrant subs, and bold coffee, making it a must-visit for both residents and visitors. Known for excellent vegetarian options and hearty portions, it offers quick, friendly service in a casual, grab-and-go setting. While some customers lament a reduced snack variety and occasional food quality issues, the overall experience remains highly positive. The welcoming staff and unique ambiance add to the charm, ensuring this spot stays a favorite stop for flavorful, satisfying meals in town.
My favorite vegetarian sandwich joint, ever. Moved to California 5 years ago, but had to drive out of our way to grab a bite while visiting NY because it is that good!
If you're in town, this place is definitely one you shouldn't miss, so I dropped in for a bagel. The sandwiches looked amazing and, based on all the other reviews, they're a must-try. The bagel I had was excellent, and the cream cheese was delightful. There isn't any seating inside, so be prepared for takeout. The service was quick and friendly, too.
A customer and an employee got into a conflict. As I was leaving the building, the customer confronted me and even yelled at my toddler. The portions of the food were not particularly generous, and the cucumbers I received were spoiled.
The food is excellent! However, the ordering process is a bit cumbersome. As a tourist, I found it challenging to know what to order or how to go about it. Additionally, I had trouble understanding the employees who were speaking through their masks. The service was also slow. That said, the cashier was fantastic and had a great sense of humor. In the end, the delicious food made the wait and confusion worth it!
I really enjoy their sandwiches, but they've significantly reduced the variety of other items for sale. It used to be fantastic—you could find a range of snacks, mac and cheese, and even toilet paper—but that's not true anymore!
Full Menu
Breakfast
Ss Potato Tots$2.0Ss Cheesy Bread Stix$5.0Cheese And Pepperoni Pizza Bagel$5.5Sandwiches
Seitan Teriyaki Sub$6.8Rbi Sub$7.7Ss Reuben$7.7
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.1 / 5 (787 reviews)#4 Seafood in Ithaca Italian Cheese
ZaZa's Cucina
Cascadilla Street 622, 14850-4049 Ithaca, US
- ★ 3.9 / 5 (4852 reviews)#1 Vegetarian in Ithaca Pizza Bars
Agava
Pine Tree Road 381, 14850-4905 Ithaca, US
- ★ 4.2 / 5 (581 reviews)#5 Seafood in Ithaca
Simeon's American Bistro
East State Street 224, 14850 Ithaca, US