Full menu with prices & pictures
Jimmy Hays Steakhous... 4310 Austin Blvd, 11558, ISLAND PARK...
+15164325155
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Jimmy Hays Steakhous...
When you're planning your visit to Jimmy Hays Steakhouse, you could take public transportation to the stop LIRR-Island Park, which is the nearest stop at 673 meters distance to the eatery, otherwise, there are parking spaces 648 meters away at Lirr Island Park-Parking Lot.
Here you can find the menu of Jimmy Hays Steakhouse in ISLAND PARK. At the moment, there are 315 meals and drinks on the menu.
Jimmy Hays, located in Island Park, New York, is a steak and seafood restaurant with a rich history. Founded by Jimmy McCluskey 75 years ago, the establishment is now run by his grandson, Jimmy Hays, who continues the tradition of personalized service. The Lobster Jimmy is a must-try dish, featuring pan-seared lobster with cognac lemon garlic sauce served over allumette potatoes. For steak lovers, the 18 oz New York Cut, dry-aged in house, is a standout option on the menu.
What Blindside likes about Jimmy Hays Steakhouse:
FANTASTIC FOOD, BUT A BIT PRICY! I always get the Seafood Tart, as I’m a big fan of seafood. It’s absolutely delicious but quite rich, so I usually take some home since I can never finish it in one sitting. I also really enjoy the Creamed Corn, the Crème Brûlée, and the Chocolate Mousse. Definitely give this restaurant a shot—you won’t regret it! View all feedback.
What Frank T doesn't like about Jimmy Hays Steakhouse:
I had another perfectly acceptable meal tonight. The ambiance was lovely, and the service was good once we figured out which of the two servers who introduced themselves was taking care of us. View all feedback.
Todd. The best steak value in New York, and the shrimp scampi and Gorgonzola cheese bread are w...
A Real Steak House as everyone like ! Service was perfect ! Food was just cooked as requested (...
Always Delicious. &my friend Martin is the best Our waiter Logan the Excellent Job.
Excellent steakhouse! The food was perfect, Valentine’s Day decorations were great! The staff i...
We drove 2 hours just to try this place out. Absolutely amazing is an understatement!! From the...