Full menu with prices & pictures
New York Pizza 1441 Old Spanish Trail, Gautier, 395...
+12285221163
Reserve a table now for New York Pizza
Here you can find the menu of New York Pizza in Gautier. At the moment, there are 33 menus and drinks on the food list.
This restaurant has garnered mixed reviews, showcasing the complexities of taste and expectation. While the allure of traditional New York-style pizza appeals to many, experiences vary widely. Some patrons laud its authentic flavors and friendly service, particularly enjoying the pizza by the slice and specialty offerings like the Chicken Bacon Ranch. However, others express disappointment over undercooked pizzas with insufficient sauce and pricing discrepancies. Despite these critiques, the establishment remains a go-to for its charming atmosphere and nostalgia, making it a worthy stop for both locals and visitors seeking a genuine pizza experience.
What User likes about New York Pizza:
Tried the Gluten-free Cauliflower crust pizza and spaghetti at this restaurant tonight. The food was delicious and the staff was very friendly. Definitely recommend giving them a try. View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about New York Pizza:
The pizza appeared appetizing, but had a lack of flavor. It was not well-seasoned. The service was good, but there is room for improvement in the quality of the food. - Judy H. View all feedback.
This restaurant serves one of the best pizzas I have tried since I moved to this area. I had it...
I recently tried pizza by the slice at this restaurant and it is not something you can find jus...
I used to love the pizza from this restaurant, but I was disappointed with my order last night....
The best Gautier pizzas Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
A must if you are in town. By far the best pizza in town! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5