Full menu with prices & pictures
Mattingly's Tavern 16 North Main Street, Florida, Unite...
(+1)8455086675
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Mattingly's Tavern
The Menu of Mattingly's Tavern from Florida contains about 44 different menus and drinks. On average, you pay for a dish / drink about $13.2.
Mattingly's Tavern is a popular American restaurant in Florida, NY, with an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers have raved about the delicious food and inviting atmosphere at Mattingly's Tavern. Stop by any time between 12:00 PM and 11:59 PM to enjoy a quick bite or make a reservation by calling (845) 508-6675. If you prefer to dine at home, you can order from Mattingly's Tavern using Uber Eats or DoorDash. Looking for a similar dining experience? Explore Sweet Onion Brewhouse and Subway for more options. Don't forget to share your favorite dishes and leave a review after your visit!.
What Mike Lipscomb likes about Mattingly's Tavern:
What a great place! Bartender was exceptional. Food was very good. Set up was very good and the ability to easily gamble on multiple platforms was a nice feature. The other patrons were friendly as well. I would absolutely recommend going there andshall return even though it is off my beaten pathway. Easy 5 star call on this establishment! View all feedback.
What Rae Sheree doesn't like about Mattingly's Tavern:
Unclean tap lines. Oktoberfest beer was soured on tap and it?s October! Bar pie was like prison food. Cook dropped our pizza to us and said ?that?s extra breading?. Whatever that means! Couldn?t even pull the ?slices? to separate. Broke a plastic knifetrying to get even a piece. It got spit out as soon as the first chew happened. Tasted rotten and hard as a rock! How are placeslike this still open. View all feedback.
One of my favorite places to order from, food is always consistently great and made exactly the...
We went here to watch some live local music. We had dinner first and the food was delicious. Th...
Unclean tap lines. Oktoberfest beer was soured on tap and it?s October! Bar pie was like prison...
The corned beef and cabbage was fantastic! The addition of M&Ms was a delightful surprise!
The delivery was incredibly quick. The steakburgers are fantastic, and the onion rings were spo...
Tavern Tots
Comfort Food at Its Best. Real, Tavern-Seasoned Tater Tots Served with Guinness Beer Cheese.