The Bay - Celina
The Bay
Menu
The restaurant from Celina offers 151 different dishes and drinks on the menu at an average price of $5.6.
Nestled in a vibrant area, Pullman Bay Restaurant offers a blend of experiences that evoke both admiration and frustration. While some guests rave about the life-changing hollandaise sauce and commend the attentive service, others report disappointing encounters marked by lackluster food and unhelpful staff. Diners have noted the inconsistent quality, from mediocre breakfast items to a delightful Club Island sandwich. The ambience skews towards traditional diner charm, appealing to many, but not all visitors find it satisfying. With training initiatives underway, there’s hope for improvement. Overall, Pullman Bay is a spot worth visiting—but be prepared for surprises.
Images
Feedback
Was Kimberly Kellogg at The Bay a mag?
The hollandaise sauce was the best I’ve ever had. I ate at this restaurant yesterday morning and can’t stop thinking about that sauce. 10/10 recommend. Life changing sauce. View all feedback.
What Deborah Jamison dislikes about The Bay:
The service was terrible! Our server vanished for more than thirty minutes, and no one else checked on us to see if we wanted more drinks. Our appetizer was unpleasant as well. I won't be returning. View all feedback.
This place is a dump. Food is lousy and overpriced. Might as well just go to McDonald's.
The hollandaise sauce was the best I’ve ever had. I ate at this restaurant yesterday morning and can’t stop thinking about that sauce. 10/10 recommend. Life changing sauce.
I had my first visit to this restaurant today with a friend. I ordered a caramel latte with extra caramel flavor, and after taking a sip, I quickly realized it was not good at all. I asked my friend to try it as well, and she agreed it was unpleasant. After only taking two sips, I asked the waitress if I could have the drink removed from the bill since I couldn't drink it. She said she would need to check with the manager. Based on the manager's attitude during their conversation, I suspected I'd be stuck paying almost $9 for the drink, and unfortunately, that’s exactly what happened. There was no apology or offer to make me a new drink or substitute it for something else on the menu. I was simply told I had to pay for it. I'm not one to complain, but I believe this situation was poorly handled, and it certainly won't encourage me to return.
I recently had breakfast at Pullman Bay Restaurant and had a wonderful experience! The food was absolutely delicious, and the service was top notch our server was attentive and friendly. Unfortunately, they were out of their famous pie, which is usually the highlight of my visit! But I was thrilled to learn that they're currently training new staff to perfect the art of making this beloved dessert. I'm excited to come back soon and try the pie once again, and I'm confident it will be just as amazing as before. Keep up the great work, Pullman Bay!
Full Menu
Seafood Entrees
Shrimp Of The Bay$12.9Pizza Lite
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Lite$5.7Pasta
Our Original Spaghetti$7.9Kids Corner (Dine In Only) Kids Eat Free Tuesday Night!
Mini Pizza Lite$3.9Sandwiches
Captain Rye-Ly$8.4Main
Dining Car Continental$3.3
More information
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 3.8 / 5 (69 reviews)#28 Fast Food in Celina
McDonald's
Grand Lake Road 101, 45822 Celina, US
- ★ 4.4 / 5 (1337 reviews)#22 Pizza in Celina
Brew Nation
110 S Main St, Celina I-45822-2228, United States
- ★ 4.1 / 5 (407 reviews)#1 Mexican in Celina
La Carreta Mexican Grill
308 E Market St Celina, OH 45822-1735, United States