Tomato Eats - Castro Valley
Tomato Eats
Menu
A comprehensive menu of Tomato Eats from Castro Valley featuring all 30 menus and drinks can be found here on the list.
Images
Feedback
Was Renee W at Tomato Eats a mag?
We hired their catering services for my son and daughter-in-law's wedding this past weekend, which had over 100 guests. Both the food and service were outstanding! I can't emphasize enough how delicious everything was. The marinated tri-tip, chicken (Cacio E Pepe with Cream Sauce—absolutely amazing), green beans with mushrooms and bacon, and garlic mashed potatoes were all cooked to perfection. The salad and sourdoug... View all feedback.
What Melinda Y dislikes about Tomato Eats:
The selection was quite limited. Besides the pre-packaged burritos kept warm under a lamp, there was a self-serve soup station and some desserts available in the cold case. I was really hoping to find a fresh Farmer's salad. I settled for the summer corn soup, which was just average. I had anticipated corn chowder, especially since the clam chowder ran out shortly after noon and wasn't available for the rest of the d... View all feedback.
The selection was quite limited. Besides the pre-packaged burritos kept warm under a lamp, there was a self-serve soup station and some desserts available in the cold case. I was really hoping to find a fresh Farmer's salad. I settled for the summer corn soup, which was just average. I had anticipated corn chowder, especially since the clam chowder ran out shortly after noon and wasn't available for the rest of the day. You pay for everything at the cash register. Overall, I was disappointed in several ways. They've really reduced the options here. I might have enjoyed the baked goods more, but I was in a hurry.
Tomato Eats has removed their hot bar food section, which is disappointing because I tried it once and really enjoyed it at the price of $10.99 per pound. Unfortunately, management explained that it's been discontinued due to a lack of a food guard to protect the food.
We hired their catering services for my son and daughter-in-law's wedding this past weekend, which had over 100 guests. Both the food and service were outstanding! I can't emphasize enough how delicious everything was. The marinated tri-tip, chicken (Cacio E Pepe with Cream Sauce—absolutely amazing), green beans with mushrooms and bacon, and garlic mashed potatoes were all cooked to perfection. The salad and sourdough bread were also excellent. All my friends and family who attended the wedding kept praising the food. I highly recommend them for catering!
For the first time, I ordered Thanksgiving dinner from Tomato Eats. They offered an 8 lb. turkey, perfect for a small family, and sides al a carte. The bird was cooked on a rotisserie with an amazing combination of herbs and stuffed with organic apples, onions and herbs. Result was moist, delicious and with crispy skin! I added potatoes au gratin and blistered green beans (yum as well) and was in Thanksgiving bliss! I'm a great cook but my turkey never was this good...they do the fuss and muss and I get a great meal? No contest! Number of meals are limited so I'm already trying to sign up for next year LOL
Tomato is like a Whole Foods buffet but behind glass. I was so happy to find it in the Castro Valley Natural Grocery Store. There were several oldish looking veggies but I bought them anyway because to be at a buffet in the age of Corona is my nirvana. I got the home fries, a dish mash of carrots, zucchini, and maybe onions, an amazing carrot dish, garlic mashed potatoes, a mini biscuit and some kind of over-cooked kale. It was all delicious! It was pricey at $10.99 a pound but like I said...I would almost pay anything to get a smorgasbord! Now sadly not all the help is great. One gal with pink hair was awesome and she helped my husband but the other helper who helped me was very unhelpful and didn 't listen. First, it took her forever to even wait on me. Then, I would say, I want a small amount and she grabs a humongous box. Then I say, I want 3 potatoes and she scooped out 20. I was like 3! 3! Finally, I opened my mask and said it again very loudly. Annoying. My husband said the turkey meatballs were good. The salad was the best, he said! I really liked the store too so I will review that next. I hope people will go so that this new food Mecca can stay in business! There are also a few other businesses inside like Japanese place, Seven Hills Bakery, a vinegar and oil place, a spice place, and a butchery. There is also a coffee shop!
Menu
Entrées
Main Courses And Sides
Italian Specialties
Soups
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
Side Dishes
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.3 / 5 (7386 reviews)#1 Seafood in Castro Valley Pizza
JP's Family Sports Lounge
3600 BlvdCA 94546, Castro Valley, United States
- ★ 3.2 / 5 (12034 reviews)#2 Fast Food in Castro Valley
McDonald's
Strobridge Avenue 1620;1632;1642, 94546 Castro Valley, US
- ★ 3.7 / 5 (3299 reviews)#8 European in Castro Valley
Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop
Rustic Drive 20674, 94546 Castro Valley, US