Casey's - Carmi
Casey's
Menu
A comprehensive menu of Casey's from Carmi featuring all 87 menus and drinks can be found here on the list.
Casey's in Carmi, IL is a popular American restaurant with an overall rating of 3.8 stars. Open from 5:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Casey's offers a variety of delicious dishes, including vegetarian options. Order your favorite meal from Casey's via DoorDash and enjoy a satisfying dining experience. Contact us at (618) 382-4670 to check restaurant availability or make a reservation. If you have a favorite dish at Casey's, share your feedback with us by leaving a review!.
Images
Feedback
Nestled in a gas-and-convenience setting, this neighborhood pizza spot draws passionate fans for reliably excellent pies—often credited to a standout pizza maker—alongside gas, donuts and friendly delivery. Yet experiences are mixed: phone and in-person service can be brusque, orders are sometimes incorrect or poorly cooked (burnt or underdone), and custom requests may be refused; missing toppings and condiments have been reported. The time-and-again contrast between great pizza and inconsistent service leaves diners divided.
I think the person who made my pizza is named Hunting. I must say, this man truly knows how to create an outstanding pizza. Every time he prepares one, it’s fantastic. It’s never undercooked or overcooked, and the quality is consistently excellent. He deserves a bonus, and I really hope he stays at Casey's forever!
The pizza here is outstanding! We also love stopping by for gas and donuts. We've never had a negative experience with their pizza. The delivery drivers are consistently courteous and friendly.
The restrooms are spotlessly clean, the customer service is outstanding, and overall, it was a fantastic experience!
Upon returning home, we discovered that half of the pizzas and the breadsticks were burnt. To make matters worse, the bacon cheeseburger arrived without any bacon, and there were no condiments provided. Given the $80 we spent, we felt more judged than valued, and it seemed like the cashier was more preoccupied with commenting on our order than ensuring the quality of the food he was preparing under harsh fluorescent lighting. Overall, the poor customer service and lack of attention to detail left us feeling like we didn't get our money's worth. Therefore, we’ve decided to take our pizza business to DiMaggio's from now on.
I would have loved to try the ultimate breakfast pizza, but the person on the phone had trouble understanding simple English. They won’t make what you want unless it aligns with their own preferences. Also, I definitely don’t recommend ordering beef or sausage on your pizza, as it will be overloaded and the crust will end up undercooked.
Menu
Add-Ons
$0.8Crazy Good Wings.
$0.8Sauces
Chicken
$0.8
More information
QR-Code for the menu
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 3.9 / 5 (661 reviews)#11 Pizza in Carmi Chinese Buffet
Lin's China Buffet
1706 W Main St Carmi, IL 62821-2263, United States
- ★ 3.4 / 5 (306 reviews)#28 Pizza in Carmi Mexican Cheese Meat
Mr Jalapeño
1340 IL-1, Carmi, USA, United States
- ★ 3.8 / 5 (1525 reviews)#9 Pizza in Carmi Mexican Casual
Tequilas Mexican Restaurant
1616 W Main St Carmi, IL 62821-2235, United States