Extra Extra Pizza - Buffalo

Pizza, Ice Cream, Cheese
549 W Utica St, Buffalo Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews, United States Of America
Dishes: 22

Extra Extra Pizza

4.9 / 5 of 490 Reviews
Phone
+17162482994
Address
549 W Utica St, Buffalo Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews, United States Of America

Opening Hours

  • Monday
    17:00-22:00
  • Tuesday
    17:00-22:00
  • Wednesday
    17:00-22:00
  • Thursday
    17:00-22:00
  • Friday
    12:00-22:00
  • Saturday
    12:00-22:00

Amenities

Reserve now

Feedback

★ 4.9 / 5 of 490 Reviews

What Scott Lawrence likes about Extra Extra Pizza:
Very good pizza and much better than most in Buffalo. The service was professional, polite and fast. It was refreshing to watch the pizza being made fresh and in a proper oven. Real artistry in display here. The pie was $27 USD for a medium with 3 toppings so above average cost but there is a no tipping culture here this surprised me. Overall, I highly recommend this spot but only gave 4 stars because it was a bit to... View all feedback.

What Ferus Priest doesn't like about Extra Extra Pizza:
We wanted to try a local pizza place while vacationing. This seemed like a good fit, so we ordered $80 In pies. Unfortunately, the large pizza we ordered came out with blackened burnt crusts the entire perimeter of the pizza, and my group was really disappointed in the texture. The other pies we got weren 't as burnt, but they were smaller pizzas we got to try toppings. The main dish of the evening was deeply disappo... View all feedback.

Moved here from Chicago and found my fave pizza in Buffalo! I got the Sicilian style with pizza...

yvette-gutierrez-lib

Real laid back place deep in the west side of Buffalo. The employees there greet you when you c...

the-lunas-forest1868

Absolutely cannot get an answer on their phone. It goes to one of two messages everytime. And I...

elliot-hammoud-2

I called explaining I like the thick thick Sicilian Pizza cheese half pepperoni.said 2 times pl...

art-rush

YES! This is the pizza that Buffalo has been missing. We ordered: a bottle of white wine, Suoli...

mak-c-4

Menu Items

More information

Related Restaurants

Fast & SimpleDownload Menu App now