Next Door - Brooklyn
Next Door
Menu
The menu of Next Door from Brooklyn includes 86 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $14.7. You can view the categories on the menu below.
The Italian restaurant in Sheepshead Bay offers a beautiful ambiance with Christmas tree and candles for every table. However, the service and food fell short for some customers, with issues ranging from waiting staff ignoring tables to overpriced items. On the other hand, for many diners, the food at Next Door did not disappoint, with highlights such as grilled octopus and eggplant parm appetizer. The restaurant was praised for its great vibe, exceptional service, and selection of regional Italian wines. Some even called it a hidden gem in Brooklyn, with phenomenal food and a must-try Nutella pizza. Overall, while some customers experienced disappointments, others found the restaurant to exceed expectations and provide a great dining experience.
Images
Reservation request for Next Door
Feedback
Was Michael Schuett at Next Door a mag?
Would never again make the trip to come here. Middling cuisine, indifferent service, very bad wine list. Maybe satisfactory for the beach crowd, but you might want to arrive already lubricated so you don 't care about the mediocrity. View all feedback.
What Colleen Mann dislikes about Next Door:
Arrived and we were the only people in the restaurant for 3/4 of our time there. Our waiter was rude and inattentive. Ordered an appetizer, entrees, 1 dessert wine bill was over $130. Not worth it. Service was terrible, food was overpriced. Overall I’d never dine here again and don’t recommend you do either. View all feedback.
I fought to eat with my man and worshiped all the experience. atmosphere was cozy, service was great, and everything we ate and drank was delicious. my man prefers plastic utensils and after finding that they make sure that a clean set for him every time we switched courses. I'm not a big pizza lover, but her signature truffle and nutella pizzas were worth trying. octopus, the dips and the Greek salate were so good! the most important courses were also delicious. we drove over an hour to visit this restaurant and would definitely return. we had a great night!
The experience was very disappointing. the ambiente and the interieur of this Italian restaurant in sheepshead bay were very beautiful. they had a lot of light and a Christmas tree, together with candles for everyone table. but everything else was very disappointing. the waiting personnel ignored my table very often, even though we tried to get their attention. they have rarely refilled our waters that have left my table and I have been very plastered and thirsty until the end of the night. the Margherita pizza was decent, and the fillet fish had a lot of bone in it. I had to spit out my fish every two seconds because there were many bones. I know fish has bones, but I'm not sure this special dish should come with everyone. because the whole waiting staff has been entertaining, it took us long to get the bill. I would not come back in general.
Eating was too salty. one of the young was so rude, because it was salty and he likes: "may be the one who is cheese". as you try. as they added as much salt to the pasta. small portions. the burger was dry and rough. never again, they don't waste their time. go to other places.
I had a great time at this restaurant. The food was delicious, the decor was decent, and the staff were very friendly.
Amazing food and phenomenal service. We were a bigger group of 8 guests with no reservation and they accommodated us without hesitation. The food was fresh and delicious, they have a variety of options and large selection of both Italian and Greek dishes. The service was efficient and the server was constantly checking on our table. You must order the Nutella pizza for desert. I highly recommend for you to check this place out if you haven’t already.
Menu
Salad
Insalata Di Rughetta E Gamberi$15.8Boards
Chef Selection Cheese Board$17.7Pizza
Flat Bread Genevose$15.8Flat Bread Vegetariano$15.8Flat Bread Piemontese$15.8Flat Bread Parma$17.7
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.1 / 5 (1968 reviews)Delis Kosher Burgers Delivery Services
Mill Basin Kosher Delicatessen
Ave T 5823, 11234-4113 Brooklyn, US
- ★ 3.7 / 5 (6447 reviews)And Grill Delivery Services Casual
Applebee's
Emmons Avenue 2505, 11235 Brooklyn, US
- ★ 4.3 / 5 (950 reviews)Japanese Salad Breakfast-brunch Ramen
Wasan Brooklyn
5th Avenue 55, 11217-2466 Brooklyn, US