Full menu with prices & pictures
Papa John's Pizza 950 County Road 64, Elmira, NY, 1490...
(+1)6073586088
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Papa John's Pizza
A complete menu of Papa John's Pizza from Big Flats covering all 3 meals and drinks can be found here on the card.
What Matthew Page likes about Papa John's Pizza:
I've been here a couple times after having avoided Papa Johns for a while, and I was pleasantly surprised by how good everything was, if I had money now I'd order up a pizza here. View all feedback.
What Lenika Cadet doesn't like about Papa John's Pizza:
I got the wrong order. I called the manager and she said bring it back to have a refund. Then she made me pay the difference for the right order and still messed up the new one. The manager is more about dancing, having fun than taking the issue seriously. Worst customer service! View all feedback.
I got the wrong order. I called the manager and she said bring it back to have a refund. Then s...
The staff were not polite& the wait time was over 15 mins for 8 slices.
Not the best quality. Some items are decent, but others were quite overcooked.
Tuesday $1 slice day for pepperoni or sausage slices! $2 for cheesesteak slices. Don't just get...
Hard working crew, but still order-accurate, friendly, and welcoming.