Pegasus Coffee House - Bainbridge Island

Nestled by the marina, this charming café boasts a rich history and an inviting atmosphere, drawing visitors with its nostalgic vibe. While the coffee and espresso drinks are often praised for their quality, experiences can be inconsistent, with some recent reports of weak brews and service mishaps. Highlights include a good selection of pastries, though recurring issues like improper decaffeination and a lack of attentiveness have marred a few visits. Although the café can get crowded, especially during peak hours, its unique backdrop and dedication to quality make for a delightful—if occasionally uneven—experience.