Amato's - Selinsgrove

The best garlic bread I've ever had in my entire life!! It has been probably 15 years since I visited Selinsgrove and had the garlic bread here. I still think about it every time I eat other, inferior garlic bread. I live across the country now and, if I could afford it, I would catch a plane right this very second to go have this garlic bread again. I tried to recreate it a few times years ago. I got close but never replicated it. It is heaven and I would probably sacrifice a limb to have the recipe. I'm not sure if I'll ever make it back to Selinsgrove. But, if I'm ever on death row, this will be on my last meal wishlist. It's that good, y'all. This is how garlic bread is supposed to be made. (I hope their recipe is still the same and never changes.

We were in the area for the night and decided to stop here for dinner. We were not disappointed. Everything was great from the time we parked until we left. The food was great and so was the staff. If we are in the area again or passing through we will definitely stop here again.

Good steak sub fresh roll. Very nice quick service, Prices were reasonable.

We've been dining at Amato's for years. The food is great, the restaurant is always clean, the waitstaff are professional and personable. We can always be confident of having an enjoyable dining experience at Amatos! Parking: Limited parking in front of restaurant, but ample parking in the back.

Took my kids here for dinner since they said they wanted pasta! We ended up getting a LG pizza and two pasta dishes. The pizza was great! I tried to eat my manicotti though and it was so salty. I couldn't eat more than one. Would've loved to enjoy it for the price that I paid for it. Kid friendliness: Three children under the age of 12 ate here fine.