Muttley's - Saint James

#17 - Pizza - Saint James, Burgers, Drinks

Muttley's

Muttley's
4.2 / 5 (185 reviews)

Description

At Muttley’s, opinions swing wildly from critique to praise. While some patrons lamented subpar food and questionable service, others enthusiastically celebrated the delicious offerings and attentive staff. The ambience seemed to resonate with many, despite occasional smoke concerns and disruptive behavior witnessed by some guests. The bar staff received consistent commendations for their friendliness, although alarming incidents regarding animal treatment overshadowed the otherwise positive atmosphere. Overall, Muttley’s appears to deliver a vibrant dining experience for those seeking good food and a lively environment, but with evident room for improvement in certain areas.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: William

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 185 reviews
not-now
18.11.2023

More like mutts, heifers and cows. Good ol big ones and big ol good ones. Nothing to see here. And certainly not the food. Have had better at any Sonic drive in, and really that's not saying much. Yeah the beer is cold. But you'd expect that from any bar you go in.. Less the cows,heifers,and mutts. Small bar. Small town. And very small minds. Save your money and your time. Find somewhere else to go. Not mutts.

beverly-edgar
18.11.2023

Food is good as long as you don't mind a long wait waitress took out money and then tried to charge us for our drinks again and $4.50 a shot is ridiculous

curtis-boulware
18.11.2023

The food and service at this restaurant are excellent! They offer some of the best pizza and appetizers in town. The average cost per person is $30–50. The food, service, and atmosphere all receive top scores of 5.

william-zinselmeier
17.03.2025

This is a wonderful, cozy neighborhood pub with a friendly and excellent staff. The patrons are lovely, and the food is fantastic—be sure to try the Muttly burger!

michael-myers-ivy0
17.03.2025

My favorite bar! The food is amazing, and the atmosphere is filled with wonderful people.

Menu

FAQ

The rooms on site are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.