Tiffany's Cafe - City of Peekskill

I visited this restaurant mainly to try their hot Cheetos elote after seeing some pictures online. I found out that it was only available for a limited time. Ho... read more I visited this restaurant mainly to try their hot Cheetos elote after seeing some pictures online. I found out that it was only available for a limited time. However, the host came over to chat with us and mentioned that it wasn't a regular menu item, but they would be happy to make it for us. When it arrived, it looked amazing and tasted just as delicious! Everything was fantastic—the food, the service, and the overall quality. They even treated us to a complimentary dessert!

If you come across this little restaurant in your search for a place to eat, I say do it! You will not be disappointed. It’s a small place but very clean and cu... read more If you come across this little restaurant in your search for a place to eat, I say do it! You will not be disappointed. It’s a small place but very clean and cute. Our server was so genuine and attentive our entire time there, and the food was amazing. We had brunch, but we went through the menu and can say they have an extremely wide variety of foods from American, Italian, to various Hispanic country foods. They served us homemade chips with this delicious home made sauce while we waited for our meals. We highly recommend you try this place out. We will definitely be going back.

Now, let’s talk about the ceviche. It’s made to order and takes about 15 minutes—totally worth the wait. I’d even wait an hour for it because it’s that exceptio... read more Now, let’s talk about the ceviche. It’s made to order and takes about 15 minutes—totally worth the wait. I’d even wait an hour for it because it’s that exceptional. The ceviche is bursting with citrus flavor, perfectly balanced with just the right amount of spice and seasoning. Every ingredient was freshly chopped, and the presentation was beautiful, served in an ornate cocktail glass. I’m quite particular about guacamole, as I often find it disappointing when dining out, but Tiffany's has the best guacamole! It’s fresh, with the perfect consistency—not too chunky and not too smooth. Each bite is more enjoyable than the last. The chips, dusted with chili lime salt, truly create a flavor explosion. The milkshakes were delightful and had just the right consistency; not too thick. We tried the strawberry milkshake, which came with strawberry churros that were simply the best I’ve ever had. They were warm, rolled in cinnamon sugar, and filled with strawberry compote. The Oreo milkshake was equally delicious. I could go on about how wonderful this place is. It’s truly exceptional, and I highly recommend it for a casual yet enjoyable dinner that’s fun and delicious.

The salmon is incredible! This little cafe really needs to spread the word about their fantastic food. The dishes here are truly outstanding! I often order the... read more The salmon is incredible! This little cafe really needs to spread the word about their fantastic food. The dishes here are truly outstanding! I often order the nachos and quesadillas—they're two of our absolute favorites. Thank you, Tiffany's staff!

Corned beef with cabbage was good Corned beef Reuben was good a tad smaller than expected Pork belly tacos were good but a little on the bland side read more Corned beef with cabbage was good Corned beef Reuben was good a tad smaller than expected Pork belly tacos were good but a little on the bland side