Bennigan's - Monahans

American, North American, Tea
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Bennigan's

Bennigan's
3.3 / 5 (2778 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive overview of all 61 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu of Bennigan's from Monahans.

Bennigans of Monahans Texas in Monahans, TX is an American restaurant with an average rating of 3.3 stars. Visit us this week from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM. Reserve your table by calling (432) 251-6236. Explore our menu and leave a review after dining with us!.

Last update: 09.03.2026 from: Crystal

Images

Bennigan's Food Bennigan's Food Bennigan's Food Bennigan's Food Bennigan's Food Bennigan's Food Bennigan's Food Bennigan's Food

Feedback

★ 3.3 / 5 from 2778 reviews

Bennigan’s provides a nostalgic dining experience that evokes fond memories of the 90s. While the appetizers and drinks consistently impress, opinions diverge regarding the main courses, particularly the ribs, which were criticized for their slimy texture and lack of flavor. Service experiences vary; some diners report attentive staff accommodating larger groups, while others experienced sporadic service. However, the classic Monte Cristo sandwich remains a standout, delighting guests with its familiar flavors. Overall, Bennigan’s offers a mix of quality experiences, making it a worthwhile visit for those reminiscing about the past.

dorothy-krajcik
05.10.2022

I have given this place many chances this was my FOURTH time here visiting. Brianna our server had the worst attitude I almost choked on my food because we didn't have any refills. Managers or owner really need to get the service here together.

herman-patricia
05.10.2022

We were SO excited to see a Bennigan's again! We were traveling and actually drove out of our way to have dinner in Monahans. Sadly, the Bennigan's we remembered from years ago wasn't what we experienced. When we arrived, there were a couple of table occupied, no one standing at the front hostess area. We stood and watched a cluster of employees chatting in the back of the restaurant but NO ONE acknowledged us in any way. My husband went to the bar and asked if we could be seated. The bartender called an employee over. This was the start of our very disappointing visit. We were taken to a table with crumbs all over it. No problem, we don't mind wiping it down ourselves...things happen. It took forever to us to get our drinks. Our server was very sweet but not service oriented. The food took around an hour to come. We thought the ticket was misplaced at some point. In their defense, the restaurant did become busier after we were seated. However, it was not THAT busy. When our food finally arrived, it was warm and not hot. Lack luster...nothing to get excited about. Our glasses weren't refilled until we asked for more tea. We watched the young employees stand around and chat while people around us grumbled about lack of service, long wait times, etc. Where is the management? We actually had 3 employees bus the table it was still dirty when they finished next to us and heard the entire conversation about the young girls breakup. Not because we were eaves dropping but because they were so loud. Bad language and personal info that no one wants to hear on a night out. Overall, I'll say it was more of a sad experience. We, like many others, have great memories of Bennigan's. This COULD be a really successful business if they had proper management.

stracke-alexandro
05.10.2022

We have chosen this place to lunch because we have eaten at bennigans all the time and enjoyed eating before they have left our opposite. this was definitely not the same quality of food. it came us cold and tasteless. service was sporadic. others came in after we had to wait to be sitting, and no one seemed to be at the front of the house. we saw four or five people in the kitchen area and two or three server, but they all hung in the back of the house. we understand the problems of the kovid and are sympathetic, but when will that be just another excuse?

crystal-contreras
23.03.2025

Were seated and waited over 20 minutes no drinks or service.do better Monahans!!! Service: 1

west-texas-lattll
23.03.2025

Very, VERY RUDELY IGNORED us, never even acknowledging she saw us waiting to be seated, let alone asking how many in our party but almost immediately seated a bi racial couple who came in 15 minutes AFTER us !?! the hostess 's actions on 2/12/25 7:30pm appeared to be racially motivated..?? Apparently we were too white to be seated..?!? Bennigan 's Manager needs to train or screen their employees better BEFORE hiring them. WORST EXPERIENCE ANY restaurant!! We left due to the rude treatment. Won 't be back to a racially profiling establishment.

  • Add-Ons

    Fruit Glaze
    Fruit Glaze
  • Starters

    Finn's Beer-Battered Fish & Chips
    Finn's Beer-Battered Fish & Chips
    The Irishman Whiskey Glazed Chicken
    The Irishman Whiskey Glazed Chicken
    Glazed Chicken
    Glazed Chicken
  • Sides

    Kicked-Up Coleslaw
    Kicked-Up Coleslaw
  • Side Dishes

    Homestyle French Fries
    Homestyle French Fries

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.