Timothy Jay Sweets - Millbury

I wish I could give more than 5 stars! I am truly impressed by both the AMAZING cupcakes and the fantastic service! I will definitely be coming back! read more I wish I could give more than 5 stars! I am truly impressed by both the AMAZING cupcakes and the fantastic service! I will definitely be coming back!

Timothy truly made my day! I'd return just for the uplifting atmosphere and the positive conversation we shared. It was tough to say goodbye! The cupcake and ca... read more Timothy truly made my day! I'd return just for the uplifting atmosphere and the positive conversation we shared. It was tough to say goodbye! The cupcake and cake pops were absolutely delicious, and he even provided candles for them since it was my birthday. My kids and I are definitely planning to go back for more heartfelt chats and to try out new flavors! I'm also following them on Instagram for the joke of the day!

We celebrated our daughter's first birthday on July 4th, but we didn’t realize many places would be closed on July 3rd and 4th. My daughter loves unicorns, and... read more We celebrated our daughter's first birthday on July 4th, but we didn’t realize many places would be closed on July 3rd and 4th. My daughter loves unicorns, and I had envisioned a beautiful unicorn cake for her special day. I stopped by Timothy Jay Sweets, hoping they would be open, and I was fortunate! The owner was incredibly helpful and assured me that he would make the unicorn cake along with a smash cake for my little girl. He went through all the options and prices with me. Everyone absolutely loved the cakes! Thank you so much for helping this mom create the cake of her dreams for her daughter!

Tim has made TWO gorgeous cakes for me now- One fun gender reveal cake for my daughter in 2022 and recently made a custom safari themed cake for her 1st birthda... read more Tim has made TWO gorgeous cakes for me now- One fun gender reveal cake for my daughter in 2022 and recently made a custom safari themed cake for her 1st birthday. Cakes always taste amazing too!! We always snag a cupcake or cookie every time we swing through too. Highly recommend the funfetti flavor for the cakes! Thank you!

We ordered cupcakes. The icing tasted funny and hard. The cupcakes tasted very dry and hard. Everyone don't like it. read more We ordered cupcakes. The icing tasted funny and hard. The cupcakes tasted very dry and hard. Everyone don't like it.