Comeback Inn - Highland

Italian, American, Pubs

Comeback Inn

Comeback Inn
4.0 / 5 (3278 reviews)

Description

This restaurant offers a mix of strong and inconsistent experiences. Diners praise the flavorful menu highlights like fish and chips, seasoned fries, and generous portions, with many appreciating the reasonable prices and friendly atmosphere—dog-friendly outdoor seating being a plus. However, recurring issues with slow or inattentive service, occasional rudeness, and cleanliness problems, such as dusty windows and unclean tables, detract from the experience. Some menu items show variable quality, and unexpected charges (like butter for breadsticks) have frustrated guests. While its charm and flavorful dishes attract many, the restaurant would benefit greatly from improved staff attentiveness and better upkeep.

Last update: 12.07.2026 from: Deb

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 3278 reviews
deb-milner-2
28.10.2024

Fish and chips are always excellent, the best anywhere. Service is usually great but two nights ago, very few customers and it took over.30 mins to get our order.

frank-combs-vine2564
28.10.2024

Good place to eat.

matt-arre-2
28.10.2024

The table we were seated at was dirty and needed to be wiped off. We had their Highland Station sandwich. The sandwich had good flavor but was lacking on the pastrami. The coleslaw on the sandwich tasted good. My family liked their breadsticks (similar to Highland House/Gus's) but, I didn't care for the amount of or taste of garlic power sprinkled on top of them.

collin-vancamp-vanca
28.10.2024

Best pizza a man can have

tiare
28.10.2024

Our order tonight included breadsticks, and although we requested butter, we were not informed (nor did the menu mention) that there would be an additional charge of $1.50 for it. Our waitress initially provided just five pads of butter for two orders of breadsticks meant for four people, and we eventually had to flag her down for more. To make matters worse, not only was the cheese moldy, but they also tried to charge us extra for butter. The service left much to be desired as well. We ordered drinks from one waitress, and just five minutes later, another waitress came to take our order again. Five minutes after that, we finally received our drinks from yet another waitress, and we were never offered any refills. Additionally, the restaurant was quite dirty. The window next to my seat had a wide shelf that was covered in dust and cobwebs, along with two dead flies. I wouldn't be surprised if this place doesn't last a year; honestly, I won’t be coming back. Update: The same flies were still there, making it feel more like eating with old friends than enjoying a nice meal.

FAQ

As a guest, you can use the WLAN of the place at no extra cost.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.