Jimmy John's - Guilderland

Sandwiches, Fast Food, Italian

Jimmy John's

Jimmy John's
3.6 / 5 (349 reviews)

Description

This charming restaurant, often referred to as a hidden gem, boasts a menu filled with delicious sub sandwiches and friendly service. While some customers appreciate unique touches, like melted cheese served in a cup, others express concerns about inconsistent quality and missing items in their orders. Regulars enjoy quick service and an easy reordering process while sampling a variety of options. Although there are occasional complaints regarding dryness or overwhelming condiment choices, the overall atmosphere remains inviting. With a positive dining experience often outweighing the negatives, this spot continues to attract loyal patrons and families alike.

Last update: 18.05.2026 from: Robert

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 349 reviews
angelica-silva-store
18.07.2024

I bought a huge order and it was a disappointment. Got these sandwiches and my moms came out wrong only 2 slices of ham on one side. I paid for a giant and we got basically a regular sandwich. This is my go to spot but I don’t think I want to return. I paid so much money and they couldn’t get the sandwich right nor did they give me my 2 whole pickles that my friend ordered at the register. Tried to give compensation with I can make a new one but you have to come and get it. If it was done right the first time and actually given all the items with the order at pick up then I wouldn’t have to drive to go pick it up. I’m disappointed and I will not be returning but I will be wanting my two pickles I paid for and that’s it. I will spread the word to my friends and family. I will also post this on social media as well.

heather-corbett-fish
18.07.2024

This is our favorite place to get subs! The staff are always very friendly, and the subs are always delicious. Kid-friendliness: Staff are always very friendly to the kids. Parking: Lots of parking outside of location.

harrison-obrien
18.07.2024

Extremely expensive. I spent nearly $16 on a "favorite combo." The JJ on New Scotland is the only location with reasonable prices. I will not be returning to this location.

robert-lewis-ii-1
18.07.2024

Great Subs with great bread. I can't resist.

tim-anderson-fern749
18.07.2024

Thinnest sub I have ever seen. Rip off.

FAQ

There is a TV / screen on-site where sporting events are broadcast.

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

You can also pay for your dishes with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.