Reviews
What Kip Gottlieb dislikes about Castle Street Cafe:
We arrived early after a matinee and expected good food and service. My wife ordered lamb, while I chose duck. She also described an appetizer as a stuffed portobello mushroom, but what came out was just a portobello mushroom with a slice of tomato and a piece of goat cheese—definitely not stuffed. My duck was served at room temperature, just like the generous portion of "garden medley" vegetables. The roasted potato... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
This is a hard review to writeCastle Street Cafe has been a regular dining stop for our family and friends for over 35 years.
I am afraid this is going to be another sad story of new ownership.
Wonderful dining room with great ambiance and attentive waitstaff My special off-menu request was cheerfully accommodated and my gf needs met.
This is a hard criticism to write. Castle Street Cafe has been a regular dining place for our family and friends for over 35 years. Most of the miracles of...
Great jazz, okay menu. I have friends who love it here, but although I enjoy the cozy surroundings and great live music, I never really find it one of my...