Panera Bread - Fort Wayne

Steak, Cheese, Sandwiches

Panera Bread

3.4 / 5 (8 reviews)

Description

Extra Toasty presents a charming atmosphere and a diverse menu ranging from hearty sandwiches to fresh salads, captivating diners with delectable flavors. While some patrons rave about the exceptional quality of the fresh bread and standout dishes like the veggie sandwich on tomato bread, others express disappointment with inconsistent service and food preparation. ToGo orders have faced issues, including incomplete items and delays due to unreliable delivery partners, casting a shadow on the overall experience. Despite these hiccups, the welcoming environment and attentive staff make Extra Toasty a spot worth considering for your next meal.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Emery

Feedback

★ 3.4 / 5 from 8 reviews
otilia06-1
24.05.2022

The sandwiches are really elevated by the fresh bread they use. The veggie sandwich on tomato bread is particularly outstanding. The half portion options are a good value and provide generous servings. The restaurant also offers tasty, fresh salads and sides.

torey-kuhn
24.05.2022

I ordered tomato soup through auto thru and got broccoli. I realized they forget cream cheese for bagels but figured soup would be ok. If you're not feeling well, the last thing a person wants to do is go back to fix it.

torey-kuhn
24.05.2022

We ordered ToGo since we are traveling for work. While the person who took our order was awesome and the Flatbread was aaamazing!! The rest took a dive off the cliff turn. The broccoli chedar soup was not even luke warm. My French onion soup did not have any cheese or croutons. The cheese is my favorite part! How can you miss the cheese!!! The baguettes we received did not impress either, one was normal size and the second one was half the size. Next time I guess we have to double check that our food was made correctly when that should not be our, the customer's, job. Especially with ToGo orders.

emery43-1
24.05.2022

Starters the girl taking our order sounded annoyed with everything. Secondly, I ordered a sandwich to split, not only was it falling apart but was not cut equally and 3/4 of the filling was in one half of the sandwich.

hbednar-horse98
24.05.2022

Generous to give a one star. Ordered 90 minutes ago. Was told it was delivered. Called and was told by a manager that they outsource to Doordash and food wasn’t picked up. Asked to speak to a manager. It was a manager. Asked when it would be delivered. Was told doordash was unreliable. Suggested I cancel order. Asked if I could be given a store credit for poor service. Was told “corporate doesn’t allow it.” Don’t order delivery from this store!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.