Casey's - Cortland

Breakfast, Lunch, Pizza
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Casey's

Casey's
3.4 / 5 (179 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Casey's in Cortland. At the moment, there are 14 dishes and drinks on the menu.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Chris

Images

Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Drink Casey's Outside Casey's Food Casey's Outside

Feedback

★ 3.4 / 5 from 179 reviews

Was Kriz Rbsn at Casey's a mag?
I'm thankful that we have a reasonably priced gas station in town. It's also a convenient spot to pick up some beer in a hurry, although I wish the prices for that were a bit more competitive with grocery stores. The service is quite good, too. View all feedback.

What Josh D dislikes about Casey's:
It’s an older Casey’s, so the store is a little darker and feels dirtier. Also, it seems to be closed at random times that would be normal for a gas station to be open. View all feedback.

a-r-pilot507
28.10.2024

So I gave the taco pizza another try and this will be the last time. Barely any chips which was part of my first complaint, hardly any tomatoes, and no refried beans... tasted like a sausage pizza. I don't understand why it's sooo bad now. Bye Casey's pizza.... When it comes to you I'm going to stick with gas because your pizza sucks!

mike-r-engineer3-1
28.10.2024

Someone stole my identity and this store let them buy 200$ worth of gift cards with no ID 9pm at night. A month later my brother had the same thing happen we had both gone there 1 time and we were together. If you go here use cash don't use a card. Someone there is running a scam.

timedpartner-s
28.10.2024

Everyone at Casey's is so friendly. It is a joy to stop in. I ordered a pizza. It was ready when they said it would be and it was delicious. Hot and tasty.

chris-r-grass35
28.10.2024

I know what you're thinking: Casey's is just a gas station. But let me tell you, their pizza is outstanding! I can already hear some of you saying I'm crazy, but trust me, it's worth it. Sure, you can't really sit down and enjoy your meal there—unless you want to sit on a case of Coke—but that's not the point. The staff at every Casey's I've visited has been friendly and easy to chat with. In fact, the team at my local Casey's recognizes me by my order, even though I only come in every few months. Their pizza features fresh-made dough, a mildly sweet sauce, and wonderfully creamy, melted cheese, making it truly delicious. They offer plenty of toppings and a great selection of specialty pizzas, including Cheeseburger, Mac and Cheese, Taco, and Veggie options. And yes, they even have breakfast pizza! Seriously, do yourself a favor and try a slice. You won’t regret it! You might want to take a menu home to contemplate your choices. Mmm, I think I'm going to go grab a slice right now!

tristen-s-4
28.10.2024

The staff at this restaurant are very friendly and always take the time to count your change accurately. They offer a range of drinks including tea, soda, coffee, and even Starbucks coffee. In addition to beverages, they serve food and have options such as water, Gatorade, Big League Chew, and a variety of snacks, which include both junk food and healthier choices. If you're a fan of Slim Jims, you'll be glad to know they have those as well.

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.