Cimaroli's Supper Club Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Erin was our waitress and boy did she make the experience even better. I don’t think I have met a better waitress. She was so funny and respectful. She was attentive and helpful. She really made us feel welcomed and valued while being extremely busy. This was a good dinner and a wonderful atmosphere. Highly encouraged you and your family to eat here to have drinks.

The last two times we have sat outside. The service was not good. This last time it was good. We will not be coming back. The waitress was not good and she was not good at bringing our refills out and rude towards us when we asked for a box.

Food is always excellent. Always hot. Drinks good and cheap. Was loud, was only complaint

Never disappoints! We arrived at 5pm and were told the wait was about 45 minutes. We got drinks and an appetizer outside and listened to the live music (which was good! . The Friday fish fry was excellent as was my son’s slow roasted duck (his favorite . My wife had the tenderloin medallions which were also good.

Food: The prime rib (1/5) was hot but not flavorful; more than expected waste to the cut—some of the worst prime rib I’ve tried. Shrimp Scampi was okay, but nothing special (3/5). The perch was okay and not heavily battered, which was good, but fish not hot (3.5/5). Broccoli was chewy, baked potato was okay (both 3/5), beans and cole slaw were good (both 4/5). Brandy Old Fashioneds (2.5/5) not that tasty and not muddled, as advertised. Receiving it after the meal made it worse. Service: 2/5–not entirely the server’s fault. Food arrived soon after ordering. Order was wrong; server didn’t catch it. Pre-dinner drinks arrived after we were finished with the meal. Waited on bill, as did tables around us. Restaurant appears to be short on help, esp the bar. Supper Club ambiance: 3/5 Overall: Although recommended by friends, this was a disappointing experience. Would not recommend.