Bagels Beyond - Feedback

Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.1 out of 5
Impressive | 10 reviews

Was Sean Toner at Bagels Beyond a mag?
I had a fantastic experience with the quick service here for breakfast when I was really hungry and didn’t want to deal with the long, chaotic lines at a place like Ferrara’s. My sandwiches were ready and delicious within 5 minutes of ordering, and the queue moved swiftly. This restaurant has a great system in place, which sets it apart from many others in Long Beach Island. View all feedback.

What Sean Toner dislikes about Bagels Beyond:
As an update this year, I'm taking away another star. Despite coming in almost three times a week because I pass by frequently and want coffee, I still feel like they treat me like a complete stranger. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Sirved
3.6 ★ from 10 reviews
alaina47
Alaina 04.06.2025 - 09:08

Kids are friendly and food is good but the service is way too slow. Even if you call ahead for pickup, they still make you wait on line. Unfortunately they cannot multitask either, take one order at a time, can't count change, etc...this place would notlast in any city but works for LBI. Update this year. Am taking another star away. Besides the fact that i come in almost 3x aweek because I I pass by that often and want coffee, they still treat me as a complete stranger and make no effort to be niceand engage a fairly regular customer for over 6 years. But what really maddens me is the quality this year really fell off. Foodis usually overly greasy and sloppy. Just thrown together without any pride in the product. Also prices have gone through theroof. I mean I get the inflation part but 14$ for a chicken wrap? The one bright spot this year is that there is a new guythere, a little older than the kids with a beard. He has personality and hopefully takes over. It would be nice to have someoneask my name after 6 years. Go down ti jersey girl grill about a mile or so south. Excellent quality with excellent customerservice.

sean-toner-mushroom0
Sean 20.11.2023 - 07:12

As an update this year, I'm taking away another star. Despite coming in almost three times a week because I pass by frequently and want coffee, I still feel like they treat me like a complete stranger.

sean-toner-3
Sean 20.11.2023 - 07:12

I ordered three bagels—two with cream cheese and one with butter—along with a cup of coffee and two kids' drinks. The total came to nearly $20.

mcglynn-allene
Allene 20.11.2023 - 07:12

My wife loves getting her favorite iced coffee from this place. The selection of bagels is impressive and really exciting, especially if you haven't tried many different varieties before. Each unique flavor makes you want to return and sample more. I'm planning to try the Lox this summer. The kids' meal featuring a bologna sandwich is my child's favorite; it’s definitely not the cheap stuff from Oscar Mayer. Plus, the kids' meal comes with chips and cookies, making it a generous portion for my 4-year-old.

sean-toner-elephant8
Sean 20.11.2023 - 07:12

There is a fantastic selection of bagels and spreads! The jalapeño spread is especially tasty!

Last update: 04.06.2025

Good Rated Restaurants near BEACH HAVEN