Casey's - Appleton City

This is my hometown, Casey, so I feel very connected to it. I appreciate that they've upgraded to better coffee machines, and they always serve great pizza. read more This is my hometown, Casey, so I feel very connected to it. I appreciate that they've upgraded to better coffee machines, and they always serve great pizza.

I occasionally visit this restaurant for lunch since I work nearby, and my experiences have generally been average. However, today's visit was not great. When I... read more I occasionally visit this restaurant for lunch since I work nearby, and my experiences have generally been average. However, today's visit was not great. When I tried to order a pizza through the app, it indicated that many of the ingredients were unavailable. So, I decided to go in and choose something from the hot food section. Unfortunately, there wasn't much available there either. In the end, I opted for a bag of chips and the only chicken sandwich they had left.

The staff seems unfamiliar with their own systems. I prepaid $100 for diesel, only to find out they were out of diesel after I had already paid and tried all th... read more The staff seems unfamiliar with their own systems. I prepaid $100 for diesel, only to find out they were out of diesel after I had already paid and tried all three pumps.

It is a very great place very clean and always helpful read more It is a very great place very clean and always helpful

They really need to hire a skilled baker because the donuts aren't even properly cooked. It seems like they just lay them out to thaw the night before and serve... read more They really need to hire a skilled baker because the donuts aren't even properly cooked. It seems like they just lay them out to thaw the night before and serve them once they're thawed. Additionally, there isn't much variety to choose from.