Pizza Plus - Windham
Pizza Plus
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Pizza Plus in Windham. At the moment, there are 40 dishes and drinks on the list.
Nestled in the Catskills, this restaurant is a casual dining spot perfect for lunch or a quick bite. It features a fun, kid-friendly atmosphere with games and a unique décor that draws visitors in. While the pizza often garners praise for its crunchy crust and flavorful toppings, some diners have reported inconsistent food quality, citing issues with appetizers and salads. Despite mixed experiences with service, many found it charming and worth the price, making it a decent choice for families or casual outings. Overall, it holds promise, especially for those craving pizza in the area.
Images
Feedback
Was You Know at Pizza Plus a mag?
Good pizza Service: Take out Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Cheese Stuffed Pizza, Wings, Cheese Pizza View all feedback.
What Rick Williams dislikes about Pizza Plus:
This was my first time there, the large pie with extra cheese and sausage was $25.00 which was more than expected, but I must admit that the pizza was very good, the customer service really sucked, there was no hello or any greeting, there was also no thank you or anything like, have a nice day, just nothing, even though a tip was given, just a not welcoming, cold feeling. Service: Take out View all feedback.
Friendly staff Pizzas are good Good location Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3
This review is fair and honestly accurate. I attempted to resolve directly with the establishment, but was unsuccessful. I was told they cannot deliver because they are short staffed, but I was told that last year as well, so apparently, they cannot get their staffing issues resolved either. After my husband picked up my order and delivered it to me, almost an hour round trip in a storm, I received a terrible meal. The only edible portion was the pizza. The garlic knots were swimming in what I believed was oil, but was corrected by the owner that the pool was butter and it 's the way people like it here . Didn 't realize there was a market cry for clogged arteries. I found this both unhealthy and inedible. The wings were horrific! A battered blob of nerve and fat coated and disguised as food. They were picked apart to find chicken, and basically 80% was thrown out! Finally, my Cesar salad was a ton of chopped iceberg, romaine and croutons- no dressing! For $9, I could have bought several heads of plain lettuce! I was told it must have been forgotten. No apology, no alternate offer. It appeared the owner felt his position was to defend and justify poor food quality and poor service. I politely said I called to give him an opportunity for explanation or correction before posting any negative review. I was told to do what I had to do , and this is it! Very, very poor customer service and very, very terrible food. Will never be back!
The pizzas were great! Would definitely come back for their good prices and it works as a good small hangout spot for people that live in the area. The service that my wife I received was excellent. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50
Pretty fantastic pizza for the middle of the Catskills! Perfectly crunchy crust, nothing chewy about it. The crazy statue in the front is also amazing. It's definitely what brought us inside. Pro tip: They sell pizza by the slice so this is a great place to hit if you're on a tight schedule. I have a family of five and we were in and out in 17 minutes! Service: Dine in
Decided to stop by this place, being in the area for another event, to give it a try. Unfortunately service and food were disappointing. When picking up we were first almost given someone else’s order and when realizing this, staff made it seem more like our fault than theirs. Customer service skills could use a big bump up here. Regarding the food, average quality for the price. Ordered two pizzas, the larger of which was the better, as the smaller one was burnt all around. Appetizers also did not have much appeal. Overall, seemed like a busy place, but improvements on service and quality would go a long way to making the atmosphere much better.
Menu
Pizza
Chicken
Sides
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 3.6 / 5 (813 reviews)#3 Seafood in Windham Pizza Italian
Millrock
State Highway 23 5398, 12496 Windham, US
- ★ 4.1 / 5 (2535 reviews)#26 Pizza in Windham American Diners
Windham Diner
State Route 23 5339, 12496 Windham, US
- ★ 4.3 / 5 (375 reviews)#4 Seafood in Windham Chinese Cheese
Qin-fang Garden
5448 NY-23, Windham, USA, 12496, United States