Gencarelli's - PINE BROOK
Gencarelli's
Menu
The menu of Gencarelli's from PINE BROOK includes 128 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $16.0. You can view the categories on the menu below.
Nestled in a cozy atmosphere, this hidden gem excels in Italian cuisine, with standout dishes like the Grandma pie and stuffed shells that evoke memories of home-cooked meals. While the food generally delights, some patrons have experienced inconsistent service, with waits that can stretch unexpectedly. The owner, Mike, is known for his personal touch, treating customers like family and ensuring a warm dining environment. Despite minor issues with certain menu items and pacing, the overwhelmingly positive feedback on food quality and dedicated service makes this restaurant a favorite for many, ensuring diners leave satisfied and eager to return.
Images
Feedback
Was Mel at Gencarelli's a mag?
Nice restaurant and excellent food. Love their delicious thin crust pepperoni pizza. I recommend the brussels sprouts and stuffed mushrooms. Will definitely be back! View all feedback.
What Berserk dislikes about Gencarelli's:
Every time I order delivery, they forget to include the drinks. I always remind them not to overlook the drinks, yet every single time, they still end up forgetting them. It's so frustrating! View all feedback.
I would not recommend the wraps from this place. Wrap was completely falling apart. It's like they made no attempt to wrap it tightly. Wasn't cut all the way through, so it just completely fell apart. Wrap contents tasted good, but quality control leaves something to be desired.
OMG Delicious! Came here because of trying to get airline bonus miles through a dining partnership, and wasn’t expecting much, but was blown away by the food selection (including ability to accommodate dietary restrictions and more! , service, and the portion size/food taste. I will make it a priority to come back again when I’m craving Italian food at an affordable price.
If it's not a pinebrooklyn pizza or a chicken cashew salad then don't get anything else from here! FOR THE LOVE OF GOD PLEASE TAKE THOSE DISCO FRIES OFF THE MENU!! Completely horrible!
Every time I order delivery, they forget to include the drinks. I always remind them not to overlook the drinks, yet every single time, they still end up forgetting them. It's so frustrating!
My favorite vodka sauce and generous portions!! And they were very good about accomodating my gluten free diet without having a reaction! Soo good!
Full Menu
Entrées
Mini Rice Balls Served With A Vodka Sauce.$15.2Roasted Sausge, Hot Peppers, Potatoes And Broccoli Rabe$17.4Deconstructed Burrata$17.4Soups
Stacciatella Romana Soup Pint$8.7Stacciatella Romana Soup Quart$14.1Salads
Small Mesclun Salad Gorgonzola Cheese W/ Walnuts$12.0
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.0 / 5 (3265 reviews)#25 Seafood in PINE BROOK Spanish
Don Pepe
Bloomfield Avenue 21, 07058 PINE BROOK, US
- ★ 4.2 / 5 (1154 reviews)#14 Seafood in PINE BROOK Salad Grill
Bonefish Grill
US Highway 46 28, 07058-9685 PINE BROOK, US
- ★ 4.1 / 5 (2104 reviews)American Salads Diners Sandwiches
Montville Diner
4 US-46, 07058, PINE BROOK, United States