Nestled in Newfane, Vermont, this bustling wood-fired pizzeria elevates casual dining with a creative menu of thin-crust pizzas, crisp fish & chips, shrimp tacos, hearty chowders and standout small plates like eggplant fries. Service is warm and attentive, staff and locals create a welcoming vibe in a chic, motorcycle-adorned space with community tables, a bar, and outdoor tented seating. Generous salads, homemade desserts and handy Tesla chargers add polish; call ahead on busy nights. Portions and beer availability have occasional limitations, but the food and atmosphere keep guests returning.

Last update: 25.01.2026 from: Curtis

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 1417 reviews

Was Nicole Alicea at Fat Crow a mag?
Walked into this spot on a rainy Saturday night with no reservations. The lovely hostess made room for us at the bar and moved chairs around to accommodate my friend and I (bless her). We sat at the bar and met some locals/regulars who were so welcoming. We ended up trying the pesto pizza which was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend this spot if you're in the Newfane/surrounding area. Service: Dine in Meal type:... View all feedback.

What John King dislikes about Fat Crow:
John's King Pizza was fantastic! I enjoyed my meal, but it would have been nice to have a beer with my pizza. The bartender was a bit hard to locate, as it seemed she kept disappearing through the back door. Despite that, I plan on coming back again! View all feedback.