Argilla Brewing Co. Pietro's Pizza
Argilla Brewing Co. Pietro's Pizza
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Argilla Brewing Co. Pietro's Pizza in Newark. At the moment, there are 40 meals and drinks on the menu.
**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag of Experiences** While this restaurant boasts some of the best pizza and an inviting, family-run atmosphere, guest experiences vary widely. Diners praise the attentive service and engaging bartenders, especially during special events. However, concerns about high prices and food quality persist, with reports of stale ingredients and unsatisfactory dishes. Some have faced unsettling cleanliness issues, such as pests, while others express discontent over the management's response to complaints. Despite these setbacks, many still enjoy the vibrant beer selection and the cozy ambiance. Ultimately, patrons are encouraged to approach this spot with cautious optimism, weighing its strengths against its notable flaws.
Images
Feedback
Was james at Argilla Brewing Co. Pietro's Pizza a mag?
This is one of my favorite spots to eat, and it’s conveniently located nearby. I've heard they occasionally have a jazz band performing, so I'm excited to come and check them out. Great food, great beer, and good times! Food rating: 5/5. View all feedback.
What Lily Z dislikes about Argilla Brewing Co. Pietro's Pizza:
So overpriced at $20 for a 10 personal pie, not to mention that they had zero issues topping it with old, yellowed out arugula that shouldn't have made it out of the kitchen. View all feedback.
This is one of my favorite spots to eat, and it’s conveniently located nearby. I've heard they occasionally have a jazz band performing, so I'm excited to come and check them out. Great food, great beer, and good times! Food rating: 5/5.
Really want to love this place but it's just so inconsistent, from the decor to the food. The place looks really nice from the outside and they have a beautiful sign, but once you get inside it just looks dingy. The food and drink are similarly inconsistent. They had 2-3 beers on the menu that were amazing but the rest were just meh. The only good food I've had on the menu is the pizza; the fish tacos (WAY over-seasoned), tots (way over cooked), etc. just didn't taste good and were extremely greasy. The beer pretzels were too dense/over-cooked and greasy. I tried two different white pizzas with different toppings that were both excellent. However we also tried the pig pineapple bbq pizza which was just not good at all. The pineapple was dry/rubbery and not sweet and the bbq sauce flavor was basically all you tasted. The only plus on this pizza was the house made sausage; you could tell it was house made when you tasted it by itself because it was excellent. Bottom line: a place like this needs to focus on what they are already doing well, improve upon that and get rid of or completely revamp what they aren't doing well in order to be great. The menu should be shorter to accentuate what they do well so people aren't disappointed and they should improve the interior decor. These would be vast improvements.
I ordered 12 wings for $18, a medium margarita pizza for $20, and a large deluxe pizza for $30. The wings were average, and the ranch dressing was pretty much just mayonnaise with a hint of ranch flavor. The pizza was disappointing, to say the least. For a $30 pie, I expected more than half of it being just sauce, with the toppings pushed to the edges. Check out the picture!
Ordered take out garlic parm wings and garlic parm fries. Fries were greasy and soggy! Wings were dry! You would think that they'll put garlic parm sauce on the wings. Nope! Just fresh garlic and no sauce, like what?! $21 wasted!
Love Argillas! Another great Freddie pie last night along with some good beers and great service from Maddy outside with our pooch. Never disappoints.
Full Menu
Pizza
Sandwiches
Side Dishes
Sauces
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.7 / 5 (2000 reviews)Halal Gyro Kebab Sandwiches Salads
Shahs Halal Food
13 Chestnut Hill Plaza, Newark, United States Of America
- ★ 3.6 / 5 (5247 reviews)American Burgers Sandwiches Hot Dogs
Wayback Burgers
South Main Street 250, 19711 Newark, US
- ★ 4.8 / 5 (2300 reviews)Japanese Sushi Soup Gluten Free
Oishii Ocean
170 East Main Street, Newark, United States Of America