Poor Gary's Pizza - Moose Lake
Menu
A comprehensive menu of Poor Gary's Pizza from Moose Lake featuring all 40 dishes and drinks can be found here on the list.
**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag of Experiences** This eatery impresses with its high-quality food and competitive prices, particularly the pizzas and subs that leave many patrons satisfied. However, inconsistent service and lengthy wait times have drawn criticism, with reports of rudeness from the staff adding to frustration. While some customers rave about welcoming staff and an enjoyable dining atmosphere, others lament missed expectations and disappointing meals. Overall, despite the promise of great flavors and positive experiences, prospective diners should remain cautious about delivery times and service quality before placing an order. With potential for improvement, this restaurant continues to attract a loyal following.
Images
Feedback
Was User at Poor Gary's Pizza a mag?
Very good pizza at a competitive price. The price is starting to inch up there so watch PG's or you won't be competitive anymore. The last price increase almost put you out of the running!!!! View all feedback.
What User dislikes about Poor Gary's Pizza:
Food is actually very good. I had to deduct a star because far too often delivery times are long. It even takes a long time sometimes when you dine in. Just ask before you order how long it will be. Make sure you have the time. View all feedback.
Great pizza. Cost a bit more, but you get what you pay in quality and taste. First order for exit, so not familiar with the staff. Based on food alone, I highly recommend.
Best food in town for the best price! Always wonderful service, even when they're busy they always have time for their customers. The Spaghetti and meatballs is half the price and twice as good as the spaghetti and meatballs from the Lazy Moose!
We tried Poor Gary's last year when we were in Moose Lake and were really impressed. Food is tasty with quality ingredients. Dough is especially good but you have to get the cheesy bread! I was glad to see they made it through the pandemic shutdown. Service is friendly and prices are very reasonable.
We placed an order for a double sausage pizza to be delivered at a specific time. The service was fantastic, the pizza tasted great, and it arrived exactly when we expected it. Well done, Poor Gary's!!
Full Menu
Beverages
Bottled Tea (Green Or White)$2.1Pitcher Of Pop$3.5Fountain Pop$2.3Specialty Pizzas
Southwestern Assembly$7.0Drinks
2 Liter Of Pop$4.7Tantalizing Appetizers
Bosco Sticks$7.6
More information
QR-code link to the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 3.9 / 5 (1069 reviews)American North American
Bowling Restaurant
4654 County Road 61, Moose Lake, United States
- ★ 4.1 / 5 (1256 reviews)American Pub Kitchen Burgers Fish Salad
Gampers
4654 County Road 61, Moose Lake I-55767-9206, United States
- ★ 3.5 / 5 (1339 reviews)Ice Cream Burgers Hot Dogs Fast Food
Dairy Queen
Arrowhead Lane 91, 55767 Moose Lake, US