Old Sarge's - McCook

#12 - Fast Food - McCook, #39 - Pizza - McCook, Pubs

114 W 1st St, McCook, NE 69001, United States

Dishes: 4

+13083452922

Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Phone

You can call the restaurant via +13083452922

Old Sarge's

★ 4.3 / 5 (724 reviews)

Nestled in a historic downtown setting, this beloved local bar offers a genuine, no-frills experience with strong, flavorful cocktails and an impressive beer selection at very reasonable prices. The atmosphere is casual and friendly, featuring classic touches like a Nebraska license plate collection, pool tables, and a dedicated outdoor smoking area. While food options are limited—pizza served only on select nights—the focus remains on drinks and socializing. Service is generally praised, though occasional lapses have been noted. Perfect for weekend gatherings or quiet reflection, this spot captures the true spirit of a neighborhood hangout.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Adam

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 724 reviews

Was User at Old Sarge's a mag?
This is a well-liked local bar, especially on weekends. They serve strong yet flavorful cocktails and a variety of mixed drinks, along with a solid selection of beers. The prices are quite reasonable—some of the best I’ve come across in recent years. It truly embodies the charm of a beloved local dive bar. View all feedback.

What User dislikes about Old Sarge's:
Rude bartender, we had our book for a buy 1 draft, get one for a penny. She seemed unfamiliar with the book, but found the stamp and stamped them, when we were ready to leave we asked her what we owed her, she sarcastically said you mean for your penny beer? We replied that it was buy 1 get 2nd for a penny, tossed 5 dollars a on the bar and left. We have been using these books for many years, never has anyone been ru... View all feedback.