Crosby's Hamlin
Crosby's Hamlin
Menu
On this website, you will find the complete menu of Crosby's Hamlin from Hamlin. Currently, there are 8 courses and drinks available.
Crosby's Hamlin in Hamlin, NY, is an Italian restaurant with an average rating of 3.4 stars. If you're curious, here's what other visitors have to say about Crosby's Hamlin. Today, Crosby's Hamlin is open from 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM. If you're interested in reserving a table or checking how busy the restaurant is, feel free to call ahead at (585) 964 3100. If you like the look of the menu but want to explore more options from similar menus, consider checking out Hamlin Pizza Shack and The Farmer's Table. If you enjoyed your meal here, don't forget to leave a review!.
Images
Feedback
Crosby’s in Hamlin provides a mixed experience that pairs commendable food with some troubling service issues. Diners have praised the food, particularly the pizza, though concerns emerge regarding items sitting in the warmer too long. While many found the atmosphere inviting and the service friendly, inconsistent staffing and a lack of familiarity with the menu items have led to frustration among patrons. Additionally, mask compliance from staff has raised eyebrows, and the cleanliness of the restroom requires attention. Still, for those seeking an affordable meal in a pleasant setting, Crosby’s remains a viable option worth considering.
Invest some into your business! Nothing works, gas pumps wont accept bank cards and employees dont turn on pumps or wrong grade or call you back into store saying card was refused only to look again and realize they were wrong. Air machine pressure gage doesnt work. Spend 1.50 and guess if your tires full. Some absolute freaks behind the counter. One was so busy watching her friend play guitar while customers waited that I and one other just left. Glad theres a new store at ridge and 260 that has equiptment that works properly
Love the store but have not ordered many subs anymore cause the last 4 or 5 only 1 was made correctly and I wait to get home so at that point id rather stop somewhere ik it will be what I had asked for. But conventient store and most employees are pleasant. 2 employees are very rude and obviously hate where they work
Absolutely the worst customer service. We walked in to place an order for a few subs...stood waiting for either of the 2 people behind the counter one just standing not wanting to acknowledge us the other fumbling with her phone when I finally asked if we could place an order I was told....well we don't have any kitchen staff. You might think they would post a sign on the counter or hire more staff!!!!!
Service has gotten terrible here! Last three times I have ordered pizza I have been told 25 minutes. Arrive at 25 minutes and the pizza has not even gone in the oven. This is a damn shame because my wife and I really like their pizza. The two guys behind the counter act like they havent got a clue. Sorry for the wait Bud just doesnt cut it!
The food is good.. some issues but usually more good than bad times ordering. Hamlin Crosby’s makes the best pizza of all the local Crosby’s for sure. Things have changed for the worse since the new owner took over, it’s still good but used to be 5 star outstanding. ie. Pizza crust has less flavor and they are almost always out of something, don’t even bother asking for cup and char because it’s been out since it launched.
Menu
American Food
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
Chicken Wings
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
More information
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 3.4 / 5 (1118 reviews)Grill American Pizza Steak Cheese
The Tavern 19
Lake Road 1549, 14464 Hamlin, US
- ★ 4.0 / 5 (1275 reviews)Pizza Pizzeria Cheese Chicken Wings
Mark's Pizzeria
430 Clarkson Hamlin Town Line Rd, 14464, Hamlin, US, United States
- ★ 4.6 / 5 (403 reviews)American North American Fish Chicken
Nuts Corners
Lake Rd East Fork, 14464, Hamlin, US, United States