The Pie Shoppe - Fincastle
Menu
A comprehensive menu of The Pie Shoppe from Fincastle featuring all 29 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.
Images
Feedback
Was Mark Wheeler at The Pie Shoppe a mag?
This charming little spot is tucked away from the usual crowds. I'm giving the food a 4-star rating for now, as I need to sample more of the menu first. The pies are definitely homemade, but the savory pie I tried was a bit dry; I expected it to have some gravy, similar to the meat pies I've made in the past. Since I've only tried one savory pie, I'll hold off on making a full judgment. However, the dessert pie was o... View all feedback.
What Jennifer Claver dislikes about The Pie Shoppe:
My husband and I visited the café, but to our surprise, there were no other customers inside. The woman at the counter informed us that we needed a reservation, or we would have to wait at least 20 minutes. I've never encountered a restaurant that operates solely on a reservation basis. We were quite disappointed! As visitors from out of town, we found this café on Google and were eager to try something new while in... View all feedback.
Service: Dine-in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
My husband and I visited the café, but to our surprise, there were no other customers inside. The woman at the counter informed us that we needed a reservation, or we would have to wait at least 20 minutes. I've never encountered a restaurant that operates solely on a reservation basis. We were quite disappointed! As visitors from out of town, we found this café on Google and were eager to try something new while in Virginia.
The pies were delicious and reasonably priced, with excellent customer service. They also offer a wide selection of whole frozen pies to take home.
There were only two young girls working, and they explained that they were short-staffed due to a larger party in the back. We were informed there would be a 40-minute wait, which we accepted. While waiting, we noticed a man who had been there for over an hour, waiting for to-go waffles. When his order finally arrived, they told him they were out of fruit. When it was our turn to order, we found that there was only one bread bowl left because the larger party had finished them all. I chose sliced bread while my daughter opted for the bread bowl. Unfortunately, when my order arrived, it was served in a bowl that was watery and far from warm. This was not the same recipe I had enjoyed at the Tea Tavern previously. The young server mentioned she would bring both the balsamic and honey drizzles, but when the food was served, she informed us that the big party had consumed all of the balsamic drizzle. Overall, the meal was not satisfactory. It would be ideal for larger parties to make advance reservations, as the staff clearly were not prepared to handle the situation. Some customers even left without waiting. During my last visit in the summer, there were two cooks and two waitresses, which made for a much smoother experience. I was truly disappointed this time around, and I believe management needs to make some changes. I felt sympathy for the young staff who were clearly overwhelmed.
The pie slices were clearly reheated in a microwave, along with most of the other menu items, as we could hear it buzzing in the otherwise quiet café after we placed our order for a few different dishes. We noticed the manager giving away free items to several customers, but we weren’t offered anything like that. As we were leaving, we overheard her speaking negatively about her staff and customers, using some rather colorful language. We had planned to make a reservation for the Rooftop in hopes of a better experience, but if it's anything like the café, we’ll definitely pass!
Full Menu
Starters
Southern Style Shrimp & Grits$21.0Restaurant Category
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
Salads
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
American Food
More information
QR-code link to the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.5 / 5 (2697 reviews)#9 Pizza in DALEVILLESandwiches
Tizzone Wood-fired Kitchen Wine
90 Town Center Street #104, Daleville, USA, DALEVILLE, United States
"The pizza was delicious, and they have the best wine selection."
- ★ 4.3 / 5 (1168 reviews)#14 Pizza in DALEVILLEAmerican
Little Green Hive Daleville
90 Town Center Street #106, Daleville, USA, DALEVILLE, United States
"Great vibes. Friendly staff. My Americano was perfect."
- ★ 4.6 / 5 (1380 reviews)#31 Pizza in DALEVILLEItalian
Lentini's
1396 Roanoke Rd, Daleville, USA, 24083-2571, DALEVILLE, United States
"This has got to be the best pizza I've had in years!"
- ★ 4.5 / 5 (2490 reviews)#18 Pizza in DALEVILLEMexican
Pancho Mexican Daleville
412 Roanoke Rd, Daleville, USA, 24083, DALEVILLE, United States
"Great food and service!"
- ★ 4.3 / 5 (2251 reviews)BurgersHot DogsInternationalCheese
Richie Freeze
4405 Williamson Rd, 24012, Roanoke, US, United States
"Finest restaurant within a 200 mile radius of Roanoke, BAR NONE!"
- ★ 4.5 / 5 (1425 reviews)ItalianDelivery ServicesPizza
Bella Pizza Italian
2716 Lee Hwy, 24175, TROUTVILLE, United States
"I ordered a large Caesar salad and a plain cheese pizza, which were delivered to my room. The ordering process through their app was quick and easy, a..."