Sebastian's - Cincinnati
Menu
The menu of Sebastian's from Cincinnati includes 40 menus. On average the menus or drinks on the menu cost approximately $4.3. You can view the categories on the menu below.
Sebastian's, a long-standing Cincinnati staple known for its delicious gyro sandwiches, has recently undergone some changes under new ownership. While some loyal customers have been disappointed with the new menu items such as greasy gyro meat and subpar grape leaves, others continue to praise the consistency of the food over the years. Despite mixed reviews regarding the quality and authenticity of the Greek dishes, Sebastian's remains a nostalgic favorite for many, offering a no-frills dining experience in a familiar neighborhood setting. Whether you're a longtime regular or a newcomer looking for authentic Greek cuisine, Sebastian's still holds its place as a go-to spot for a tasty gyro in Cincinnati.
Images
Feedback
Was Joey at Sebastian's a mag?
A must if visiting Cincinnati! I've had my fare share of gyros but the Gyro that they serve( usually served by a little Greek man named Alex) is phenomenal. You gotta get it with extra tiziki sauce! View all feedback.
What Jim Mercer dislikes about Sebastian's:
The new owner has ruined Alex's world famous food. The new gyro meat is greasy and the sauce doesn't even come close and appears to be canned bought. The new grape leaves are disgusting. I spit them out. The atmosphere is new and looks clean but they have lost/disposed of the old world European eatery. What a shame.Food: 1/5 View all feedback.
I love the gyros! Took a long break after new owners took over, but that was my loss. The food is good if not better than before. The interior certainly looks a lot better; I actually considered dining in during my last visit. And, no small matter, but they accept credit cards, now!!! I miss seeing Alex there, but he obviously left the place in really good hands.
The new owner has ruined Alex's world famous food. The new gyro meat is greasy and the sauce doesn't even come close and appears to be canned bought. The new grape leaves are disgusting. I spit them out. The atmosphere is new and looks clean but they have lost/disposed of the old world European eatery. What a shame.Food: 1/5
Love this spot! Authentic and very charming! Food was absolutely fantastic.Food: 5/5
Food is always good at Sebastian's. Just wish the restaurant was a bigger place. Really small in there.Food: 5/5
They have the best gyros in the city no doubt about that. And their cucumbers sauce is sooo good! There fried are perfect too!Food: 5/5
Full Menu
Famous Salads & Dinners
Small Greek Salad W/ Gyro Meat Pita$6.7Sandwiches
Gyro (Year-Oh)-Our Specialty$5.0Side Orders
Dolmathakia (Grape Leaves)$1.2Large Order Of Gyro Meat$8.5Small Order Of Gyro Meat$6.5Extras
Extra Sadziki Sauce$0.5
More information
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.9 / 5 (1151 reviews)Drinks Bars Venues Cocktail Coffee
The Brick Yard Bar
2038 Madison Road Cincinnati, OH 45208, United States
- ★ 4.8 / 5 (1071 reviews)Breakfast-brunch Burgers Sandwiches
Sugar N Spice Restaurant
Reading Road 4381, 45229 Cincinnati, US
- ★ 4.8 / 5 (2187 reviews)#1 Vegetarian in Cincinnati American
Shaan Indian Cuisine
Paxton Avenue 3880, 45209 Cincinnati, US