Petrella's Express - Chili
Petrella's Express
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Petrella's Express in Chili. Currently there are 54 dishes and beverages in the menu.
Nestled within a gas station, Petrella's defies expectations with its exceptional homemade cuisine. Diners rave about a diverse menu featuring standout options like delicious pizzas—especially the Buffalo Chicken—and an array of hearty sandwiches. The buffalo chicken sub boasts fresh ingredients, while thoughtful combinations in wraps, such as the avocado BLT with turkey, showcase the owner's commitment to quality. Homemade pasta, including gnocchi and meatballs, further elevates the experience. Despite its unconventional location, Petrella's invites anyone seeking vibrant flavors and freshly prepared meals to indulge and discover why this eatery has quickly garnered a loyal following.
Images
Feedback
Was Frank U at Petrella's Express a mag?
How is it possible for gas station food to taste so good? I was really doubtful about the reviews, but my wife and I decided to give this place a shot. Let me tell you, we’re hooked! So far, we’ve tried the pizza, which was incredible, the chicken Parmesan sub, which was fantastic, and the steak sub, which was also amazing! Trust me, you need this place in your life. View all feedback.
What Jennifer M dislikes about Petrella's Express:
I visited this restaurant today after hearing such great reviews, but to my disappointment, it was closed! It’s unfortunate because I was looking forward to enjoying some delicious food. When will North Chili realize that there’s a college nearby full of hungry customers eager for something worthwhile to catch their attention? View all feedback.
You might not expect it from the exterior, as Petrella's is located inside a convenience store, but my first visit revealed that the owner was making homemade pasta from scratch, which piqued my interest. I started with a buffalo chicken sub, and it was delicious—fresh fried chicken breast strips topped with quality sauce and crumbly blue cheese, all served on a fantastic 8-inch sub roll. No corners are cut here! Next, I ordered a turkey wrap, which was beautiful. It featured turkey, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, a peppadew aioli, and havarti cheese. Amazing! These thoughtful additions and careful preparation are what make this place stand out. Then I tried a wicked chicken sandwich, which was Cajun marinated and topped with Swiss cheese, crumbly blue cheese, and a touch of country sweet sauce. There was also a chipotle bacon turkey sandwich with smoky bacon chipotle mayo and havarti cheese—fantastic! Additionally, the chicken parm sandwich was another winner, boasting chicken pounded flat and served with house-made tomato sauce and mozzarella. To top it all off, I enjoyed one of the best meatball subs in Rochester. I’m quite particular about meatballs, and these are homemade, as is the sauce, all served on a high-quality Italian roll—just fantastic. There are still many other items I want to try, including the shaved steak with beer butter garlic sauce, a grilled chicken pesto sandwich, and a smoky A1 burger, to name a few. So, I recommend ordering ahead, waiting patiently (because fresh takes time), leaving your diet at home, and simply enjoying the experience. By the way, the pizza is delicious too!
I love this place! The food is fresh and flavorful and not your average gas station food. Every time I get something different it always surprises me how good it is! Their pizza is great, I like their buffalo chicken personally! The avocado BLT is so good I add turkey it's fantastic with the special basil mayo.
This place is amazing! I've tried most of the sandwich and wrap options on the menu and I still can't decide which is my favorite! I'd definitely recommend Petrella's if you're looking for a good lunch option.
Petrella's is an odd place as it is in a gas station but don't let that fool you: the food is fantastic! The pizza is amazing, especially the Buffalo Chicken pizza. He makes homemade pasta, including ridiculously good gnocchi. The Mediterranean salad is delicious and has organic marinated chicken. If you're looking for a good lunch on the west side of Rochester, this is the place to be.
What a great surprise! Had it for dinner last night for the first time and we tried a variety of things including the white pizza, avocado blt sandwich, fries, alfredo fettuccine and a quinoa salad. We couldn't believe that fresh, made from scratch, quality ingredients would come from a place that is located inside a convenient store/gas station. Everything was so good. We will be regulars and look forward to trying many other dishes. Don't overlook this place, it's a hidden gem!
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.2 / 5 (4173 reviews)American Greek Breakfast French Family
North Chili Family
Buffalo Rd 4405, 14514-1046 Chili, US
- ★ 3.2 / 5 (203 reviews)Breakfast Lunch Donuts Coffee Bagels
Dunkin'
4371 Buffalo Rd, Chili I-14514, United States
- ★ 3.7 / 5 (1452 reviews)Italian American Pasta Salad Pub
Six50 Black Oven Cooking
3765 Chili Ave, Chili I-14624-5252, United States