Settepani Bakery - Brooklyn
Settepani Bakery
Menu
The restaurant from Brooklyn offers 29 different menus and drinks on the menu at an average price of $13.5.
Settepani Bakery is a family-run, Sicilian-inspired pastry shop known for authentic, handcrafted treats like cannoli, pistachio panettone and rainbow cookie croissants. Many praise its warm hospitality and traditional flavors, but others report inconsistent execution—overly sweet or greasy creams, dry sponges, and occasional service or custom-cake mishaps. A neighborhood favorite with bold flavors, it’s ideal for pastry lovers but approach special orders with caution.
Images
Feedback
Was Augusto Laspina at Settepani Bakery a mag?
Settepani Bakery truly embodies the spirit of a family-run business in every way. Bilena and her family are incredibly welcoming, and it’s clear they pour their hearts into what they do. The quality of their baked goods is exceptional—each item is made with care and passion. As a proud Sicilian, I couldn’t recommend Settepani Bakery enough. If you’re looking for authentic, top-tier pastries, this is the place to visi... View all feedback.
What Michelle S dislikes about Settepani Bakery:
The cannoli was decent, but there are better choices available. The cupcake was alright—just your average cupcake, nothing noteworthy. However, the tiramisu was a big letdown. It wasn’t the mini cake as advertised, and it tasted like low-quality coffee essence. Overall, it wasn't good, especially considering the price. View all feedback.
Everything is incredibly delicious! I will definitely order again for parties or just for everyday treats. The service was excellent as well!
The cannoli was decent, but there are better choices available. The cupcake was alright—just your average cupcake, nothing noteworthy. However, the tiramisu was a big letdown. It wasn’t the mini cake as advertised, and it tasted like low-quality coffee essence. Overall, it wasn't good, especially considering the price.
I'm not sure how this restaurant has such great reviews, but the desserts I had were terrible! The ratio of chocolate to cannoli filling was overpowering, and the cream inside was excessively sweet. The cakes looked nice but tasted awful. There was an imbalance between the cake and the cream; there was way too much cream, which wouldn’t have been an issue if it had been good. The cream had a greasy taste, and they seemed to try to mask the poor quality of the ingredients with sugar, making the cakes overly sweet. The sponge cake at the bottom was dry and crumbled when I tried to cut into it. Overall, it was overpriced.
I was trying to buy coffee, but no one was there. Lady just left pretending she doesn’t see us. She was not returning for long time. Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1
Settepani Bakery truly embodies the spirit of a family-run business in every way. Bilena and her family are incredibly welcoming, and it’s clear they pour their hearts into what they do. The quality of their baked goods is exceptional—each item is made with care and passion. As a proud Sicilian, I couldn’t recommend Settepani Bakery enough. If you’re looking for authentic, top-tier pastries, this is the place to visit. Keep up the fantastic work! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Meal type: Other Price per person: $20–30 Recommended dishes: Bakery, Cannoli, Rainbow Cookie Croissant, Pistachio Panettone, Biscotti
Menu
Most Ordered
Classic Panettone (1 Kilo)$39.6Bread
Hero Loaf$2.5Market Items
Partanna Olive Oil 100Mls$6.9Pitted Castelvetrano Partanna Olives$8.9Blood Orange Sicilian Marmalade$7.9Partanna Olive Oil 500 Mls$15.8
More information
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.1 / 5 (1968 reviews)Delis Kosher Burgers Delivery Services
Mill Basin Kosher Delicatessen
Ave T 5823, 11234-4113 Brooklyn, US
- ★ 3.7 / 5 (6447 reviews)And Grill Delivery Services Casual
Applebee's
Emmons Avenue 2505, 11235 Brooklyn, US
- ★ 4.3 / 5 (950 reviews)Japanese Salad Breakfast-brunch Ramen
Wasan Brooklyn
5th Avenue 55, 11217-2466 Brooklyn, US