Varney's - Brookhaven

#22 - Seafood - Brookhaven, American, Burgers

Montauk Highway 2109, 11719 Brookhaven, US

Dishes: 46

+16312869569

Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Phone

You can call the restaurant via +16312869569

Varney's

★ 4.4 / 5 (2072 reviews)

Varney's has long been a cherished spot for seafood lovers, offering a warm, community-focused atmosphere and friendly service. Diners rave about the delicious lobster rolls, fresh seafood, and standout dishes like the chicken cutlet parmesan. While many love the casual vibe and delightful key lime pie, mixed reviews emerge regarding pricing transparency and certain menu items, such as the chicken Caesar wrap. The restaurant’s popularity means reservations are a must on weekends, but for those willing to embrace a slower-paced dining experience, Varney's remains a go-to for satisfying seafood and an inviting charm.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: James

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 2072 reviews

Was Marisa Passaro at Varney's a mag?
I’ve been wanting to go here forever since I always pass it. The place is cute and cozy with plenty of outdoor seating. We decided to sit outside. Service was great. I ordered the lobster roll, cold. It was fantastic. I definitely wanna come back and get it again. My fiancé got the burger and he says it was delicious. The menu had plenty of good options, so we’ll definitely be back. View all feedback.

What Christina Brink dislikes about Varney's:
It was ok. I’ve had worse but I’ve had better. I guess i was expecting a little more flavorful especially for almost $50 for a lobster roll and fries. I would suggest you change your menu pricing online considering it says the lobster roll and fries are $24 and I was charged $40 View all feedback.