Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Gatsby's Landing:
Excellent dining experience. We were able to eat on the patio overlooking pond. Beautiful evening. Staff were very attentive. Food was absolutely delicious from appetizer to the dinner and dessert. Not rushed. Manager came out to greet us. Everything was wonderful. View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Gatsby's Landing:
1st time here food was MEDIOCRE, except the bread butter is good. We got a bunch of specials including: bao bao lobster rolls very little lobster meat salmon crudo overloaded with Mayo, makes you question the quality of the salmon swordfish DRY, a lot of unseasoned rice, barely any vegetables, and the pineapple tastes OLD, canned, as if it were sitting out near cleaning supplies all day. Then lamb chops partner said ok, and it only comes with farro, which was so dry and plain... NO VEGETABLES!.
Sorry Gatsby's, the first visit was a disappointment. It started with excellent bread, then my meal went downhill. The lobster bisque special was like broth, not creamy at all. The “famous” Gatsby's vodka sauce was OVERPOWERED with cheese. I never tasted the sauce. The staff was excellent and the manager very friendly. Maybe just a bad night.
Beautiful restaurant next to the water. This restaurant has one of the best views in Long Island. The host (she) is really nice and the servers are phenomenal. The foods are amazing and we will definitely go back again.
Was there for lunch on a Saturday. Was happy there was a price fixe. The food was delicious! Huge portions and lunch came with dessert. I had chicken francaise, two nice size portions My friend had the skirt steak salad, also delicious and large portion. Will definitely go again.
Beautiful place. Great food and wonderful atmosphere. Staff is very attentive and there are so many selections to choose from. Would definitely recommend this place.
Came w family and baby. We had an emergency and had to leave shortly upon arriving. Ordered lunch to go for 9 people yesterday and we had to leave. Brianna our waitress was SO nice and accommodating. The maître d' was also very helpful and kind. Brianna took great care of us even though we weren’t staying to eat. Food was packed really carefully- labeled well and delicious. Gatsby’s service is top notch
More information
QR-code link to the menu
