Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Earnestine Steuber likes about Barnaby's Family Inn:
really neat old character of this pizza restaurant, somehow reminds me of an old shakey’s pizza. eating was quite fast, very tasty, the only reason for the 4 stars is that the staff could have been much more friendly, and a bit more cleanliness had brought into a five stars. View all feedback.
What Raven Heidenreich doesn't like about Barnaby's Family Inn:
Barnaby's pizza is a rare find anymore. A old wood interior pizza restaurant. They have been in Tallahassee for years. I feel the food used to be better though. The old guy isn't there nagging the employees to make it the exact same every time. And that is what you used to get. But I never know if there will be to much sauce it but enough and that kind of thing but they still make a great pizza. View all feedback.
Take out, you wish they had a crash. He waited about 10 minutes for our order, but appreciated that they cooked the cheese bread fresh when we arrived. We ordered 3 mini pizzas (which we added Marinara sauce as the crust was a dryer chest). The pizza was delicious and I would order it again! The spaghetti and meatballs were enjoyed. My only proposal is the curb-side experience for those who do not want to wait for where workers and customers do not wear masks.
I used to like going here, but tonight was awful. First off the employees were walking around in the food area eating. I asked for my wings to be fried hard, they wasn't. I ordered 3 mini pizzas and they all were very salty and seemed to cook to long. Will not be going back any time soon. Need some serious adjustments.
I'm not exactly sure what happened to the pizza at Barnaby's, but the last 2 times we have picked up, it has been pretty bad. We didn't ask for extra cheese, but the pizza had about 1/2 and inch of semi-warm cheese. As for the topping (pepperoni) it wasn't evenly distributed. I'm sad to say, I won't be going back, unless I hear something good from a reliable source. Also, the employees were arguing with each other in front of all the customers.
The best pizza in tallahassee! I've been here for 40 years. now, where I live in Georgia, I still go to tallahassee for the spaghetti and meatballs and get a pizza to go home later. great food!
The personal makes them welcome and are very helpful. pizza was delicious. Unfortunately, barnabys suddenly went out of business to disappoint the staff. some found jobs other restaurants. people are generous for server as they make only $5.00 plus tips.
Full Menu
Appetizers
Pizza Snacks
Sides
Sauces
More information
QR-code link to the menu
