Old Mystic Country Store - Stonington

My family absolutely loves this place! I always enjoy the best breakfast sandwiches, and my kids can't get enough of the grinder. The pizza is consistently hot and fresh! I'm excited to support Tony and help make it even better!

Incredible! Words can't truly capture the amazing experience we had! We hosted a party with around 40 people, and Tony and Chantel went above and beyond to create unbelievable pizzas. The Big Mac pizza and the Suppenpizza were huge hits! I highly, highly recommend this place!

The restaurant was difficult to locate, and I wasn't sure if it was open late enough to try the pizzas shown in the photos. It seems that they typically operate as a breakfast spot for local workers on their way to their jobs. We ordered breakfast sandwiches, which were quite good, but I recommend avoiding the bulky sandwich and opting for the croissant or bagel versions instead. Overall, we had a decent experience during our breakfast visit, and the young staff members were impressive in their management.

The inside of this place is very unique! Lots of really cute items from artisanal sauces/seasonings to face masks to destination signs. Definitely a fun place to shop with lots of Mystic souvenirs. I heard a lot of good things about the food here so I ordered a little bit of everything to try. This included a Buffalo chicken pizza, 5 cheese pizza with meatball, cheesy bread, and chopped pasta salad. The Buffalo chicken pizza was a traditional Buffalo chicken white pizza and had lots of real fresh chicken. The 5 cheese pizza was great with real meatball chunks and the marinara tasted very homemade. The cheesy bread was my favorite, garlic bread topped with lots of cheese and served with marinara. Above all the salad was amazing. SUPER FRESH from the chicken to the cherry tomatoes, everything was delicious. The lettuce was bright, green, crisp romaine. I ordered it with the garlic dressing on the side which I highly recommend!!

We are so happy this business continues to operate. Great breakfast Sandwiches, Pizza is fabulous with amazing crust (Try the Chicken Broccoli Alfredo) and delicious sweets in the pastry case.