Nick's Pizza And Clam - Smithtown

I don't know if it was what I ordered but everything I ordered had zero taste, overcooked and lacked flavor. I should have been put off by the star rating on yelp but I wanted to give it a chance since it seems like a Smithtown institution. WELL I was wrong. Don't bother! AVOID!

I love the location even in the winter! The Clam chowder is homemade and very very delicious. We also got the mussels with the garlic cream sauce, which was very rich and tasty. Pretty large amount too. Great selection of food and a variety of beer. The owner/chef was very pleasant and friendly. You can tell he loves what he does. The only only criticism I have is that they use styrofoam plates and bowls and I think that could switch to something a little better.

Have been there twice because I am living in the area! Outdoor dining and no serving staff (and thus no tips required lol , but overall good dining atmosphere on sunny summer days! Like their clams, always so fresh! Also recommend the mussels! Their serving sizes are large and worth the prices. We left with our bellies full :

I've seen this place in passing but I've never stopped in til this weekend. It's a place where you order up front and grab your food when your buzzer goes off. The food itself is delicious! I got the lobster roll which was packed full of lobster. Someone else in my party got a fried soft shell crab which as delicious and not greasy at all. We shared steamers which were absolutely to die for, and fresh too. The pizza looked amazing and I wished I had ordered some but there's always next time definitely recommend, super tasty and relaxed!

We luv Nicky's (as we call it! bcuz it's become a summer tradition to sit outside, drink a beer, watch the traffic stream by on 25A while the kids run up and down the little hill adjacent to the eating/picnic area. They serve Excellent Steamers that never disappoint...and of course...the pizza is good too! We also like the soundtrack(s they play, so it's a win-win way to spend a couple of hours outside summer chillaxin LI-style.