Giacalone Pork Pasta Deli - Shirley

I ordered 8 heros from them for company I was hosting on the weekend.I was overcharged like CRAZY and they forgot one of my sandwiches .when I called to let them know they forgot one, they said, that’s what was on the ticket. no offer to make the sandwich, no resolution.the sandwiches we did get were lacking in taste and freshness. totally not worth the $17 I paid for EACH sandwich.

My boyfriend and I came here for breakfast for the first time to try it out. We ordered an egg sandwich and an egg platter. The food was fresh and made just right. The woman behind the counter was very polite and generous. She gave us a taste of their fresh mozzarella, still warm. It was absolutely delicious! My boyfriend felt like he was back home in Brooklyn. We finally found our new favorite spot. We will definitely be returning soon and often.

Great Mom n Pop shop. My Sisters have been coming here for years and it’s always been a warm hearted experience and good conversation and quality food. No better place here in Shirley and it’s totally great during the holidays.

Feels like you are dropped in Little Italy when you enter. Then the homemade choices will blow you away. And you dream of the dish when you get home and are never disappointed. Always a cut above!

This place could be good, but the bread is always frozen. (Check their freezers out front. You can literally see hero’s in there). The lady is super nice. She try’s to remember your order but she forgets every time. I’m not kidding. If they cared about their food this place would be a gem. But bc they consistently mess up for have frozen hard hard bread they have lost a costumer for good.