Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Five Star Pizza Sarasota:
Excellent customer service. Extremely fast pizza (under 5 minutes from placing a special order until it was ready! . The bathroom was clean, lobby clean and the pizza was fast and exactly what I ordered. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. Excellent customer service. Extremely fast pizza (under 5 minutes from placing a special order until it was ready! . The bathroom was clean, lobby clean and the pizza was fa... View all feedback.
What Kelly N doesn't like about Five Star Pizza Sarasota:
Awful customer service! Rude. Rude. RUDE! No one in there makes eye contact with you or has any manners. You say thank you and get ignored. Kid’s at Chic Fil A have better customer service than a few of the adults that work at this place. You could learn a thing or two from them! Service: 1 View all feedback.
Meh, I don't know how they have so many five star reviews. Pizzas are mediocre, crust tasted oddly chewy, almost undercooked. At least the Door Dash was quick and the pizzas were both correct and hot. I wish I would have read more reviews and not just looked at the overall rating.
Ordering is easy whether online or over the phone. Pizza is amazing! Delivery was fast as pizza was as hot as it just came out of the oven.
Good old school pizza. Could have cooked the GF crust a little bit more. Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free Crust Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20
The best pizza ever I will only order from five star!! And their staff is always incredible! Food is always hot and fresh and way faster than expected wait time! Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20
Best pizza EVER (updated 8/25/24): Order their veggie pizza, add feta, spinach, ham, and a 20% tip. You will be in awe; orig review follows: Five stars for Five Star Veggie pizza, add spinach feta Best pizza in town. Snappy delivery, great management support. (One time we had a problem and the manager drove us a new pizza himself to make sure we were happy) This is the spot. Vegetarian options: If you add feta and spinach to the regular veggie, it's awesome!
Full Menu
Mexican-American Food
Chicken
Salads
Toppings
More information
QR-code link to the menu
